Charley Walters: J.J. McCarthy will have to beat out a veteran to be the Vikings’ QB in 2026

Vikings General Manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and Coach Kevin O'Connell have made it clear that they intend to bring in a veteran quarterback to compete with third-year QB J.J. McCarthy for the starting job next season.

The veteran quarterback, whoever it is, is expected to be the starter, not McCarthy. The reason Daniel Jones signed with the Colts last year rather than re-signing with the Vikings was that he thought he had a better chance of winning the starting job in Indianapolis than beating out McCarthy.

McCarthy will have to beat out his competitor, not be handed the starting job. The only other option that makes sense is Kyler Murray. The Vikings could aim higher, but teams aren't going to trade away top players like Joe Burrow or Lamar Jackson.

It's a good bet that the Vikings already have discussed with Justin Jefferson their quarterback plans for next season: Someone who can get him the ball. There are some technicalities involved in the way Kirk Cousins' contract is structured, but basically, the Falcons will have to wait until March 12 to cut him loose.

Signing Cousins would cost the Vikings between $15 million and $20 million. Cousins sold his $1.25 million Inver Grove Heights home nearly two years ago. Regarding Murray, if the Cardinals keep him on their roster by mid-March, $20 million of his $27 million contract becomes guaranteed. If Arizona releases him, they would owe him $36 million next season.

Aaron Rodgers, who had a level of professionalism this season but doesn't have the physical talents he once had, is unlikely to be the Vikings' first choice after being overlooked last year. His Hall of Fame career probably is over.

The Indiana Hoosiers won all 16 games without cheating, which is really hard to do even now despite NCAA revenue sharing and Name, Image and Likeness (NIL). The reason for their success may have been that they didn't have as much NCAA revenue sharing and NIL money as the Gophers. Heisman Trophy winner Fernando Mendoza was only a two-star recruit out of high school in Miami.

Twenty-two Indiana players transferred from James Madison University in Virginia, which gives hope for the Gophers. Minnesota's problem is that it doesn't have the same coach as the Hoosiers, Curt ("I win. Google me.") Cignetti.

The Vikings will need to find a way to get Justin Jefferson the ball next season. Someone who can do that needs to be in the quarterback position.
 
🤔 I think the Vikings should aim higher and target a QB with more upside, like Kyler Murray or even a young gun from the draft 🏈💪. If they settle for someone like Aaron Rodgers or Daniel Jones, it might not be the best use of resources, considering their age and lackluster performance this season 😐. Plus, Justin Jefferson deserves to see more action on the field, so the QB situation needs to improve ASAP 👍.
 
🤔 man, it's like when you're tryin' to figure out your career path, ya know? You got these options, but which one is gonna lead u there? 💼 Like how the Vikings need a QB, but not just any QB, one that can get Justin Jefferson the ball 📦. It's all about findin' the right fit, like how Coach Cignetti did with Indiana, and maybe we can learn from him too 👨‍🏫.

And it's interesting how Daniel Jones thought he had a better shot at winnin' in Indy than beatin' out J.J. McCarthy 🤔. That's like when you're tryin' to get ahead in life, but sometimes you gotta take risks and step outside your comfort zone 🔥.

It's also crazy that Kirk Cousins' contract is so complicated 😂. Like how some things just come with strings attached, ya know? 💸
 
🤔 I don't really get why teams keep bringing up all these different QBs for their starting jobs... like, which one is going to actually win it? It's just going to give everyone a headache! 😩 And what's with the rumors about Daniel Jones wanting to play in Indy instead of here? Can't we just keep our own guys? 🙄
 
omg I'm so down for the Vikings to bring in a vet QB this offseason 🤩! it makes total sense that Daniel Jones went to Indy over re-signing with Minny, he wanted a shot at winning the job. and Kyler Murray is a great option, but maybe they can aim higher? joe burrow or lamar jackson would be insane signings 🤯 I'm not sure about Aaron Rodgers tho, he's lost some of that magic 💔

anyway back to the QB situation... someone who can get Justin Jefferson the ball ASAP needs to be in the mix 🏈. it's crazy how many players transferred from JMU to UofM, maybe that's a sign of things to come? 🤝 and yeah, Cousins' contract is gonna be a thing next year 💸
 
🤔 The whole situation with J.J. McCarthy vs veteran QB is just like the old-school democrat vs republican debate - "who gets the job first?" 🏈 The Vikings are basically saying "we're gonna bring someone in to compete" which sounds like a compromise 🤝, but it's still gonna be hard for McCarthy to beat out that veteran QB. And on another note, have you seen how the NCAA revenue sharing is creating some crazy recruiting situations? It's like they're saying "oh, you want to go to Minnesota? Well, we'll give you all this NIL money... just please don't cheat 😏". Meanwhile, back in the NFL, it's all about finding that QB who can get Justin Jefferson open 📈. And with Cousins' contract, it's like they're saying "we might not be able to afford our own QB, so we'll have to wait and see what the Falcons are doing" 🤑. It's all just a big game of chess out there 😏.
 
OMG 🤯 I'm loving the Vikings' moves on this one! It's about time they brought in some veteran QB depth, especially since J.J. McCarthy is still young and has potential but needs a solid starting QB to thrive 💪.

I'm so done with Aaron Rodgers being considered for the starting job though 😒 he just doesn't have it in him anymore. And please, no more Daniel Jones drama... if the Colts wanted him that bad, they should've signed him already 🤷‍♀️.

But for real tho, Kyler Murray or Justin Fields would be AMAZING additions to the team 🤩. Whoever they choose has to be able to get Justin Jefferson the ball ASAP because let's be real, he was the real MVP last season 😎.

And can we talk about how underrated Curt Cignetti is as a coach? Like, I know the Hoosiers are on fire and it's cute... but Minnesota needs him like yesterday 🙌.
 
omg did u hear about the new coach of the indiana hoops team? 🤔 i'm so confused about college sports... they just won 16 games w/o cheating lol what's NCAA revenue sharing? how does it affect the game? and btw, who is that one heisman winner fernando mendez? 🤷‍♀️ also, u think aaron rodgers can come back to the vikings? 😂 i don't think so... btw, why do the falcons have to wait till march 12 to cut kirk cousins loose? cant they just do it now? 😒
 
omg I'm so hyped about the Vikings QB situation 🤩!! I think they should go for Kyler Murray, he's got that elite level arm talent and can make plays outside of the pocket 🔥🏈. And honestly, J.J. McCarthy needs to step up his game if he wants to compete with someone like Murray 😬. It's gonna be tough to beat out a guy who was signed by Daniel Jones himself, but I think the Vikings have what it takes to make it happen 💪. Justin Jefferson is gonna need someone who can get him open and I'm convinced that's the key to this season 📈
 
So I'm thinking if the Vikings wanna keep it competitive they need to get a good QB in place ASAP 🤔💡 They already have a top WR in Justin Jefferson, but he's not gonna make himself open with just anyone throwing the ball to him 😅 The problem is they can't be handed the starter job, whoever that might be. I think Kyler Murray is the only legit option, but teams aren't exactly parting with their stars like Joe Burrow or Lamar Jackson 🤑 Either way, it's gotta be someone who can put the ball in Jefferson's hands consistently 👍
 
So, the Vikings are looking for a veteran QB to start next season, huh? 🤔 That makes sense, but I gotta correct you - it's not McCarthy who's gonna win the job, but whoever comes in as the veteran QB! 😂 And if Jones signed with the Colts last year because he thought he had a better chance of winning, that just means he wanted to be starter material.

It's also super smart of the Vikings to think about Jefferson's needs - someone who can get him the ball ASAP is gonna be key. As for Cousins' contract, yeah, that's some technical stuff, but I'm no lawyer... basically, they gotta wait 'til March 12 to cut him loose.

If the Cards keep Murray on their roster, he's gonna make a whole lot of money next season. 🤑 But Rodgers? Unlikely starter candidate - Aaron's got some miles on his body now.

And those Indiana Hoosiers? They're not cheaters! 🙅‍♂️ I mean, it's hard to win 16 games straight without any issues, but yeah, maybe they just didn't have as much cash to throw around like the Gophers.

Cignetti's departure from the Gophers is a problem, though. And 22 players transferring in? That's some serious roster rebuilding on their part!

All in all, getting Jefferson the ball next season is key - someone who can deliver that's gonna be the QB. 💪
 
😊 So I'm not surprised about the Vikings' plan to bring in a vet QB, gotta make it tough for McCarthy to prove himself 🤔. I think Kyler Murray is an interesting option but we'll see if the Cardinals want to hold onto him... $36 million is a big price tag 💸. Aaron Rodgers might be too old to lead the Vikings anymore, let's be real 😐. The Gophers need a coach change ASAP, Curt Cignetti just doesn't have the same magic as Coach Ryan or even Mike Kafka 🤷‍♂️. What I do hope is that whoever they sign at QB can get Justin Jefferson the ball more often, he needs a reliable outlet to make plays downfield 🔥. The Colts signing Daniel Jones was no surprise either, Indy knew what they were getting with him 😎
 
idk about this whole QB situation for the Vikings 🤔. think they're barking up the wrong tree with Kyler Murray, he's not worth $20 million. Aaron Rodgers might be old news now 😴. and what's with all these veteran QBs? can't they just find a young gun who's actually got it 💪? and have you seen Justin Jefferson's highlights last season 🤯? dude was on fire! shouldn't the Vikings be trying to get him more involvement in the game, not just relying on some new QB to throw him the ball 📦. think they're missing the boat here...
 
😊 I think its gonna be tough for J.J. McCarthy to beat out whoever gets brought in as a vet QB... like you said, Daniel Jones chose Indy over Vikes 'cause he thought he had a shot at startin' 🤔 and Kyler Murray makes sense too but teams aren't tradin' away their top guys 😐 I mean, Joe Burrow & Lamar Jackson are kinda untouchable 💪

But you're right, the Vikings need someone who can get Justin Jefferson the ball... that's like, his bread & butter 🍞💨 Cousins is an option but it's gonna cost 'em around 15-20 million 🤑 and Rodgers is prob not their first choice since he didn't exactly have a stellar season this year 😐
 
🤔 So I think it's pretty clear that the Vikings are trying to upgrade their QB situation, and they're not afraid to spend big to make it happen 💸. The idea of signing Daniel Jones or Kyler Murray is definitely intriguing, but at the end of the day, it's all about finding a guy who can get Justin Jefferson the ball 🤯.

I'm not sure what happened with Jones last year, but if he thinks he's got a better shot at the starting job in Indy than McCarthy, then he's probably right 💡. But for the Vikings, it's all about competition and pushing their young QB to be his best.

And let's be real, signing Aaron Rodgers is a long shot 🤷‍♂️. He may have been professional this season, but physically, he's just not the same guy he was 5 years ago. I think the Cardinals would be crazy to keep him if they can get out of his contract.

But here's the thing: the Hoosiers' success story is actually kind of inspiring 🙌. I mean, going undefeated without cheating is no small feat, and it's definitely worth looking into for a team like Minnesota that could use a little bit of inspiration on their sidelines.

The fact that 22 Indiana players transferred from James Madison to U-Minn gives hope that they might be able to turn things around 🌟. And yeah, having the right coach can make all the difference – Curt Cignetti's got some work to do if he wants to get his team back on track 😬.

Anyway, I'm just hoping the Vikings can find a QB who can put Justin Jefferson in position to succeed. That's what it's all about 🎯!
 
🤔 I think the Vikings are onto something here. Signing Daniel Jones or Kyler Murray would definitely give them a boost, but they gotta consider their options carefully 📈. Aaron Rodgers might not be the first choice, and Cousins' contract is kinda tricky 💸. I'm intrigued by the idea of Justin Jefferson getting more attention in the passing game, it's been lacking lately 😐. Maybe someone like Murray or Jones can bring some excitement to that department? 🎯 The question is, are they willing to take a chance on someone new and risk losing out on a proven winner like Daniel Jones? 🤷‍♂️
 
idk why the vikings would sign joe burrow 🤔 they already got some serious firepower with jefferson and dalvin cook... kyler murray would be a decent move tho, he's shown he can make plays with his legs and arm 👏 but it's all about finding that QB who can get jeff to the ball 🔴💨
 
Back
Top