Elgar: The Dream of Gerontius album review – Gardner and the LPO's reading is bold and dramatic

A new interpretation of Sir Edward Elgar's 'The Dream of Gerontius' has emerged, thanks to conductor Edward Gardner and the London Philharmonic Orchestra. This latest addition to the repertoire is a bold and dramatic reading that showcases the composer's complex emotions.

In contrast to the quiet introspection often associated with Elgar's music, this performance bursts forth with vibrant energy. Tenor Allan Clayton delivers a striking portrayal of the dying man, whose every sensation is both an intense fear and an unsettling fascination. His powerful tone soars in the iconic Sanctus Fortis, imbuing the piece with a sense of heroism.

Soprano Jamie Barton brings a lush mezzo-sound to her role, infusing the philosophical discussions between the dying man and his angelic guide with an unshakeable comfort. Bass James Platt's deep voice is perfectly cast as the Angel of Agony, bringing depth and gravitas to the character.

Conductor Edward Gardner drives the narrative forward with a boldness that borders on operatic intensity. The London Philharmonic and Hallé choirs deliver stunning performances, creating an overwhelming sense of drama that propels the listener through the work. While some may find the recording's acoustic limitations slightly less than ideal, this minor quibble is easily overlooked in light of Gardner's electrifying leadership.

In comparison to other recent recordings, such as Nicholas Collon's Finnish account, this latest 'Dream of Gerontius' stands out for its visceral intensity and dramatic flair. It is a testament to the enduring power of Elgar's music to move and disturb us, and a must-listen for anyone who loves the composer's work.
 
This new version of The Dream of Gerontius sounds AMAZING 🤩 I mean, I've always loved Elgar's stuff but this one has me super hyped! Allan Clayton as the dying man is perfection - his tone is so powerful it gives chills every time. And Jamie Barton as the angel guide? Forget about it, she brings such warmth and comfort to that role. The way conductor Edward Gardner brings all these emotions together is just masterful 🎵 I've already got this on my playlist and I'm listening to it nonstop!
 
Wow 🤩 this new interpretation of "The Dream of Gerontius" sounds AMAZING!!! I'm all about that dramatic flair and intense energy - it's like they're speaking straight to your soul 😊. And Allan Clayton's voice is just insane! 💥
 
🎵👏 I gotta say, this new interpritation of 'The Dream of Gerontius' sounds AMAZING!!! 🤩 Edward Gardner is a genius conductor! I love how he brings out the bold and dramatic energy in Elgar's music, it's like you can feel the emotions radiating through your speakers. Allan Clayton's performance as the dying man is giving me all the feels 😭 and Jamie Barton's soprano voice is so lush and rich! 💖 The angelic guide, James Platt, adds this perfect contrast to the piece with his deep bass. Can't wait to listen to it myself! 🎧
 
This reading of The Dream of Gerontius is kinda overhyped, if you ask me 🤔. I mean, don't get me wrong, the London Philharmonic Orchestra is on point as always, but I think we're making a big deal about this conductor, Edward Gardner. He's got some great ideas for arrangements and all that jazz, but it's not like he's inventing the wheel here 😂. And have you heard Nicholas Collon's Finnish account? That was actually pretty amazing 🎵. I mean, I love Elgar as much as the next guy, but this new recording just feels like a bit of a rehash to me. Still, it's not bad by any means... I guess 👌
 
I'm loving this new interpretation of 'The Dream of Gerontius'! 🎵 Edward Gardner is a genius on the podium - his energy is infectious! I mean, Allan Clayton's performance as the dying man is just wow... he brings so much emotion to that piece. And Jamie Barton's mezzo-sound is like butter for your soul 😍. I'm also loving the Hallé choirs - they add this depth and richness to the whole thing. My only gripe is with the acoustics on this recording, but honestly, it's a minor complaint 🙄. Nicholas Collon's Finnish account is still great, but there's something about this one that really gets under your skin... I think it's because it's so raw and emotional!
 
Back
Top