A jury in Peoria, Illinois, has started deliberating the case of Sean Grayson, a 31-year-old sheriff's deputy accused of first-degree murder for fatally shooting Sonya Massey, a 36-year-old Black woman who called 911 after spotting a prowler outside her home.
The nine-woman, three-man jury must decide whether Grayson is guilty of murder for responding to the emergency call and mistaking it for a potential threat. According to eyewitness testimony from fellow deputy Dawson Farley, Grayson ordered Massey to drop a pan of hot water on the stove, which she had left on, sparking a tense exchange.
In a heated moment, Grayson threatened to shoot Massey after she uttered a rebuke in Jesus' name, and told her not to move. But instead of following orders, Massey ducked behind a counter, prompting Farley to claim he was initially intimidated by the hot water.
Prosecutors argue that Grayson's response was unreasonable and violated Massey's right to safety in her own home. They point out that Massey did drop the pot, but only after repeating herself, suggesting she wasn't intent on using it as a weapon.
Defense attorney Daniel Fultz, however, urges the jury to consider how Grayson felt at the time of the incident, rather than judging him 15 months later. He claims Grayson was trying to gain Massey's compliance and prevent any potential harm by drawing his gun.
If convicted of first-degree murder, Grayson faces a sentence of 45 years to life in prison. The jury will also consider second-degree murder charges, which carry a lighter sentence range of four to 20 years or probation.
The nine-woman, three-man jury must decide whether Grayson is guilty of murder for responding to the emergency call and mistaking it for a potential threat. According to eyewitness testimony from fellow deputy Dawson Farley, Grayson ordered Massey to drop a pan of hot water on the stove, which she had left on, sparking a tense exchange.
In a heated moment, Grayson threatened to shoot Massey after she uttered a rebuke in Jesus' name, and told her not to move. But instead of following orders, Massey ducked behind a counter, prompting Farley to claim he was initially intimidated by the hot water.
Prosecutors argue that Grayson's response was unreasonable and violated Massey's right to safety in her own home. They point out that Massey did drop the pot, but only after repeating herself, suggesting she wasn't intent on using it as a weapon.
Defense attorney Daniel Fultz, however, urges the jury to consider how Grayson felt at the time of the incident, rather than judging him 15 months later. He claims Grayson was trying to gain Massey's compliance and prevent any potential harm by drawing his gun.
If convicted of first-degree murder, Grayson faces a sentence of 45 years to life in prison. The jury will also consider second-degree murder charges, which carry a lighter sentence range of four to 20 years or probation.
... so the cop is saying he was just trying to protect himself and Massey, but it seems like a pretty clear case of mistaken identity. I mean, come on, she called 911 because she saw a suspicious person outside her house - that's not exactly a reason to start yelling at someone who's already in distress.
... like, what even is going through his head? And then she ducks behind the counter and he gets all upset again... it just seems like a big mess. I'm not saying Massey was perfect or anything, but this cop's actions seem way out of line.
... 36 years old is way too young to be gone. And the fact that the jury has to consider second-degree murder charges just shows how complicated and flawed our justice system can be 
and that pan of hot water could've been a deadly force if she hadn't ducked out of the way 
it's crazy how one heated moment can escalate into something so tragic.
i think the prosecution has a point in saying that his response was unreasonable. it's like, we all want to stay safe, but how do we balance that need with personal freedom and human dignity? this case is just a harsh reminder that even when our intentions are good, things can go so wrong 
. The whole situation with Dawson Farley coming forward and saying he was intimidated is pretty sketchy too... it's like, Grayson's already got the upper hand as a law enforcement officer, does he really need to take it out on his own citizen? 
.
just thinking about this is crazy... the fact that a deputy shot and killed someone he was supposed to be helping is just wow 
. some people might need a little more guidance on how to handle tense situations like that 
.
not at all understanding how that phone call escalated so fast. and that moment where she says jesus' name? that's just wow... you can't even imagine being in those shoes, i would've been super scared too 
The fact that he was all like "don't move" after she says a prayer... it's just wild.
and wasn't it a police siren outside her house or something? just doesn't sit right with me... 
. Nine women and three men trying to weigh all the evidence and emotions from that day - it's just mental exhaustion waiting to happen 
. And let's be real, how do you even prepare your mind for something like this? I mean, I've seen some wild stuff on the internet, but a jury deliberating over murder? It's just...wow 
. And now they're trying to spin it like he was just trying to protect her, but I'm not buying it 
. Can't we just have fair and reasonable policing for once? 
. And the fact that her fellow deputy was intimidated by it is just heartbreaking.
.
. The fact that he threatened to shoot her after she spoke out of turn is just crazy 
. I'm keeping my thoughts on Grayson for now, but what about the jury deliberating? Will they find him guilty or give him a lighter sentence? My heart's going out to Sonya's family during this difficult time 
#JusticeForSonya #PoliceAccountability #RIPMassey