Man Fatally Shot by NYPD in West Village After Pointing Fake Gun at Officers, Second Fatal Shooting This Week
A 37-year-old man was fatally shot by the New York Police Department (NYPD) in the West Village after he allegedly pointed a fake gun at officers. The incident occurred around 10:50 p.m. near Bedford Street and Sixth Avenue, where two people had reported a car crash involving a BMW.
According to Assistant Chief James McCarthy, commanding officer of the Manhattan South patrol borough, the NYPD responded to the scene after receiving reports of the car accident. Upon arrival, officers approached the vehicle and a 37-year-old man stepped out, pointing what appeared to be a gun at the officers. The officers fired, but the man continued to hold onto the fake weapon as they commanded him to drop it.
EMS workers arrived on the scene and took the man to a local hospital, where he was pronounced dead. The identity of the deceased has not been released by authorities.
Witnesses described the sound of gunshots and sirens in the area, with some reporting that they heard over 20 shots fired during the incident. Neighbors said the street was silent for a moment before a large police response arrived, including paramedics and additional officers.
"This was super scary," said neighbor Saad Cheema. "I've never heard gunshots in my life. It almost felt like it was inside my apartment."
The West Village shooting is the city's second fatal NYPD shooting this week, following another incident on Thursday involving a man who barricaded himself in a room at New York-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital.
In both incidents, police reported that the individuals involved had been armed with fake guns. Authorities have said they are conducting internal investigations into both shootings.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote on social media that the shootings were "devastating to all New Yorkers" and pledged to work with Commissioner Jessica Tisch to ensure a thorough investigation.
The NYPD's force investigation division is reviewing both incidents, including whether mental health professionals could have been deployed to deescalate the situations. Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal called for increased accountability from manufacturers of imitation guns, citing state legislation he passed in 2022 to ban such items.
A 37-year-old man was fatally shot by the New York Police Department (NYPD) in the West Village after he allegedly pointed a fake gun at officers. The incident occurred around 10:50 p.m. near Bedford Street and Sixth Avenue, where two people had reported a car crash involving a BMW.
According to Assistant Chief James McCarthy, commanding officer of the Manhattan South patrol borough, the NYPD responded to the scene after receiving reports of the car accident. Upon arrival, officers approached the vehicle and a 37-year-old man stepped out, pointing what appeared to be a gun at the officers. The officers fired, but the man continued to hold onto the fake weapon as they commanded him to drop it.
EMS workers arrived on the scene and took the man to a local hospital, where he was pronounced dead. The identity of the deceased has not been released by authorities.
Witnesses described the sound of gunshots and sirens in the area, with some reporting that they heard over 20 shots fired during the incident. Neighbors said the street was silent for a moment before a large police response arrived, including paramedics and additional officers.
"This was super scary," said neighbor Saad Cheema. "I've never heard gunshots in my life. It almost felt like it was inside my apartment."
The West Village shooting is the city's second fatal NYPD shooting this week, following another incident on Thursday involving a man who barricaded himself in a room at New York-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital.
In both incidents, police reported that the individuals involved had been armed with fake guns. Authorities have said they are conducting internal investigations into both shootings.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote on social media that the shootings were "devastating to all New Yorkers" and pledged to work with Commissioner Jessica Tisch to ensure a thorough investigation.
The NYPD's force investigation division is reviewing both incidents, including whether mental health professionals could have been deployed to deescalate the situations. Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal called for increased accountability from manufacturers of imitation guns, citing state legislation he passed in 2022 to ban such items.
like, can we talk about these NYPD shootouts? 
they're literally flooding the streets and scaring people half to death 
. I mean, a fake gun is not worth dying over 
. We need some real solutions here 
.
. It's clear that our current system is not equipped to handle these situations effectively 
.
The average number of civilians shot per year has been increasing by 10% since 2015 
.
Most fatal shootings occur during the first hour after a call is made to 911.
, not just more guns 
. And we need manufacturers of imitation guns held accountable for their products 
. This is not a political issue, it's a human issue 
.
. But what if we could take a step back and try to understand the situation from another angle? Would it have made a difference if the man had just talked to someone instead of pointing a fake gun? We should think about de-escalation techniques, not just force 
. It's also telling that neighbors were terrified, but one guy remembered the scene like it was inside his apartment - that's how real trauma can be 
its like theyre just looking for any excuse to use their guns. i mean i know cops have a tough job but u gotta wonder if these fake guns r being used as a way to test them out or somethin 
anyone else think this is a conspiracy to make it look like cops r more aggressive than ever? 
people need to be more careful lol 
btw did anyone see that new superhero movie? its soooo good 
. its like what r we doin wrong here? r we still havin problems w/ fake guns? how many times gotta we lose someone b4 we take action? 
. anuthin else i dont get is why the police didnt jus try 2 deescalate w/ mental health profs 
.
]
.
. We need to make sure our law enforcement agencies are equipped to handle these types of incidents without putting innocent lives at risk 
in the West Village. It's really frustrating that we have to see gun violence happening all too often on our streets. I mean, who carries around a fake gun at night? 
.
- if we had a section on gun safety and fake guns, it would be really helpful in spreading awareness about this issue 
i feel bad for da families of da victims & all da other ppl in da community who r livin in fear 24/7 
the nypd needs to step up their game & make sure they r prepared 4 situations like dis 
That's not an option, and now some poor guy is dead. Can we blame it on those fake guns though? 
. But at the same time, are they even designed to look realistic? Like, is that fake gun just begging to be mistaken for the real deal? 
the police gotta do everything they can to keep us safe 
not violence 
manufacturers need to take responsibility for their products and we need better de-escalation tactics 
. Can't we all just get along?