The Matchbox Girl by Alice Jolly review – horror, humanity and Dr Asperger

"The Matchbox Girl" by Alice Jolly is a harrowing and haunting novel that navigates the complexities of human experience during World War II. The story follows Adelheid Brunner, a mute autistic girl who finds herself at the center of a dark narrative in 1930s Vienna.

As Adelheid navigates the hospital where she is being held, she observes the doctors - including Dr. Hans Asperger - who are fascinated by her and her fellow patients. Jolly skillfully weaves together historical fact with fictionalized events to create a sense of tension and unease that propels the reader through the narrative.

One of the most striking aspects of this novel is its exploration of what it means to be human in the face of unimaginable horror. Adelheid's inner voice, though silent, is powerful and poignant, offering glimpses into her thoughts on love, loss, and survival. Her observations on the world around her are both chaotic and beautiful, offering a unique perspective on the war-torn city.

While Jolly's writing can be fragmented at times, mirroring Adelheid's own fractured inner world, she ultimately manages to craft a compelling narrative that balances historical accuracy with emotional resonance. The result is a novel that feels both deeply personal and universally human.

Throughout the book, Jolly raises important questions about what destroys humanity - and what might save it. Asperger's legacy looms large in the background of this story, but Jolly avoids simplistic interpretations or didacticism, instead opting for a nuanced exploration of the complexities of human experience.

Ultimately, "The Matchbox Girl" is a testament to the enduring power of the human spirit, even in the darkest of times. Adelheid's story is one of hope and resilience, offering a powerful paean to the humanity that the Nazis sought to destroy.
 
💡 I just finished reading "The Matchbox Girl" by Alice Jolly and I'm still reeling from the experience 😱. The way Jolly weaves together historical fact and fiction is like a masterclass in storytelling 📚. But what really gets me is how Adelheid's inner voice, despite being silent, feels so alive and real 💖. It's like she's speaking straight to your soul, you know? And the themes of hope, resilience, and humanity in the face of unimaginable horror are just so powerful 🌟. Jolly raises some really important questions about what makes us human and how we respond to trauma, but in a way that feels thoughtful and nuanced rather than heavy-handed 🤔. Overall, I think this book is a must-read for anyone looking for a powerful and emotional story 💥.
 
🤯 I just finished reading this book and OMG it was so intense! The way Jolly weaves together fact and fiction is like nothing I've ever seen before 📚. Adelheid's character is literally haunting me, her silence is so powerful it's like she's screaming right through the pages 😱. And Asperger's legacy is still super problematic, but Jolly does a good job of showing how complex his story is without being simplistic or judgmental 🤔. The writing style can be weird sometimes (I know what you mean by fragmented), but it fits with Adelheid's inner world and makes the whole thing feel even more realistic 🌪️. Overall, this book is like a punch to the gut in the best way possible 💥.
 
I just finished reading this book and I gotta say its got me thinking about how we perceive people with autism and mental health issues 🤔. The way Jolly portrays Adelheid's inner world is so vivid and thought-provoking, it feels like you're right there in her shoes experiencing everything through her eyes. Its interesting to see how the doctors who were fascinated by these patients back then viewed them as specimens rather than people with agency.

Anyway, I loved how the author balanced historical accuracy with emotional resonance - its not always easy to tackle these types of themes without feeling like youre hitting someone over the head with a moral 🙄. The writing can be a bit fragmented at times but I think thats part of the point, it reflects Adelheid's own fractured inner world and adds to the sense of unease that permeates the entire book.

Overall Im really impressed with Jolly's nuanced exploration of the human condition - its not always easy to find books that tackle these themes without feeling didactic or simplistic.
 
🤯 I just finished reading this book and I'm still reeling from it! The way Alice Jolly weaves together historical fact and fiction is pure genius 😲. I love how Adelheid's inner voice is so powerful, even though she can't speak. It's like her thoughts are screaming at us to listen 🗣️. And the way Jolly explores what it means to be human in the face of unimaginable horror is just...wow 💥. Asperger's legacy is definitely there, but Jolly handles it with such care and nuance. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time, wondering how Adelheid would survive. And that ending? 😭. Just when you think you know where the story is going, it takes a sharp turn into hope and resilience 💪. Trust me, this book will stay with you long after you finish reading it 📚.
 
I just finished reading "The Matchbox Girl" 📚😱 it's honestly so messed up, you know? I mean, the way Jolly weaves together fact and fiction is genius... like, I was totally invested in Adelheid's world even though she couldn't speak herself 🤯. The way the author shows how the doctors were fascinated by these kids with autism, it's just so haunting... like, what were they thinking?! 😒

And Asperger's character, ugh, he's just so... complicated. I feel like Jolly is trying to say something about him, but she doesn't want to simplify it or make it into some sort of hero worship thing 🙄. It's all so nuanced and stuff.

But anyway, the book is literally haunting me, in a good way? 😅 Like, Adelheid's inner voice is just so powerful... I don't know how someone who can't speak can have such thoughts and feelings 🤯. And the writing style at times is so fragmented, it's like you're right there with her, experiencing everything through her eyes 👀.

Anyway, I think that's why this book is so important - it's not just some historical fiction thing, it's a reflection of humanity... even in the darkest of times 💔.
 
I just finished reading this book and I'm still reeling from it 🤯💔. As someone who loves historical fiction, I was both fascinated and unsettled by Adelheid's world - it's like being trapped in a time capsule of darkness and fear. But what really got me was how Alice Jolly wove together fact and fiction to create this haunting narrative 📚. The way she explores the complexities of human experience during WWII is so thought-provoking, and I love how Adelheid's silent voice speaks volumes about her inner world 💡. For me, it's a powerful reminder that even in the face of unimaginable horror, there's always hope to be found ❤️.
 
omg i just finished reading this book and it's giving me all the feels 😩📚 i feel so bad for adelheid she's just trying to survive in this crazy world and these doctors are like studying her like she's some kinda lab rat 🤯 it's like, what even is wrong with humans? but at the same time i love how jolly writes about adelheid's thoughts and feelings, it's like we're right there with her experiencing everything she's going through 💕 and the way asperger's legacy is woven into the story is so cool 🤔
 
Back
Top