The Federal Occupation of Minneapolis: Why Minnesota Can't Stop It
Thousand of masked federal officers with uncertain authority are rampaging through the region, assaulting protesters and innocent people, abusing constitutional safeguards, staking out daycares and schools, snatching people off the streets in unmarked vans based on their skin color or accent, and recklessly provoking violent confrontations with civilians – all against the loud, repeatedly expressed wishes of local and state officials.
Minnesota's government has few options that wouldn't trigger something like civil war. Despite repeated pleas from Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey and governor Tim Walz to President Donald Trump to call back his operation, the federal occupation shows no signs of ending.
The reason lies in the fundamental principles of American federalism. A key part of this principle is that a state cannot really resist federal authority or kick out federal law enforcement officials. This is because the federal government is meant to be the "protector" of last resort if local and state officials fail to uphold the rights of ordinary citizens.
President Trump's actions, however, threaten the very union of the United States. By deploying immigration officers and border security agents from the DHS, Trump is changing the nature and tenor of his federal force. These agents are not trained to normal federal law enforcement standards and are meant to operate with severely limited authority to enforce immigration matters.
Trump has attempted to use troops in similar crackdowns over the last year and been stymied by federal courts. If he were to invoke the Insurrection Act, it could give him cover to circumvent restrictions on deploying troops without state approval.
The residents of Minneapolis are facing a full weight of Trump's masked secret police, but the spreading and growing resistance to the Trump administration shows that protesters nationwide are courageous in the face of federal assault.
Thousand of masked federal officers with uncertain authority are rampaging through the region, assaulting protesters and innocent people, abusing constitutional safeguards, staking out daycares and schools, snatching people off the streets in unmarked vans based on their skin color or accent, and recklessly provoking violent confrontations with civilians – all against the loud, repeatedly expressed wishes of local and state officials.
Minnesota's government has few options that wouldn't trigger something like civil war. Despite repeated pleas from Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey and governor Tim Walz to President Donald Trump to call back his operation, the federal occupation shows no signs of ending.
The reason lies in the fundamental principles of American federalism. A key part of this principle is that a state cannot really resist federal authority or kick out federal law enforcement officials. This is because the federal government is meant to be the "protector" of last resort if local and state officials fail to uphold the rights of ordinary citizens.
President Trump's actions, however, threaten the very union of the United States. By deploying immigration officers and border security agents from the DHS, Trump is changing the nature and tenor of his federal force. These agents are not trained to normal federal law enforcement standards and are meant to operate with severely limited authority to enforce immigration matters.
Trump has attempted to use troops in similar crackdowns over the last year and been stymied by federal courts. If he were to invoke the Insurrection Act, it could give him cover to circumvent restrictions on deploying troops without state approval.
The residents of Minneapolis are facing a full weight of Trump's masked secret police, but the spreading and growing resistance to the Trump administration shows that protesters nationwide are courageous in the face of federal assault.