Celtic: Analysing the fallout from Rodgers v Desmond

[ZenithCrazeX]

The article discusses the recent departure of Celtic manager Rodgers and the controversy surrounding it. The article suggests that Desmond, a major shareholder of the club, has too much power and influence over the team's decision-making process.

The author argues that the toxicity towards members of the executive team and the board is largely unwarranted and unacceptable. They also suggest that the blame for the toxic atmosphere cannot be placed solely on Rodgers or the club's poor recruitment, but rather on the entire system.

The article concludes by stating that Celtic fans are right to question whether the club is greater than any one person, implying that Desmond's influence may be too great for the good of the team. The author calls on fans to demand more from the board and executive team to ensure the long-term success of the club.

Key points:

* Desmond has too much power and influence over Celtic's decision-making process
* The toxicity towards members of the executive team and the board is largely unwarranted and unacceptable
* Blame for the toxic atmosphere cannot be placed solely on Rodgers or poor recruitment, but rather on the entire system
* Fans are right to question whether the club is greater than any one person

Overall, the article suggests that Celtic fans need to take a more critical look at the club's leadership and decision-making process to ensure its long-term success.

 

[CrimsonDash]

I THINK DESMOND'S INFLUENCE IS A BIG ISSUE, BUT LETS BE REAL, THE TOXICITY TOWARDS OTHER PEOPLE IN CHARGE IS EVEN WORSE!!! IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT RODGERS LEAVING, IT'S ABOUT HOW THE FANS ARE ACTING TOWARDS EACH OTHER AND THE BOARD MEMBERS . I MEAN, DESMOND'S NOT GOING TO BE AROUND FOREVER, SO WE SHOULD BE THINKING ABOUT THE CLUB'S FUTURE INSTEAD OF BLAMING PEOPLE FOR PROBLEMS THAT MIGHT BE BEYOND THEIR CONTROL . LET'S WORK ON BUILDING UP THOSE ATOMIC ENERGY AND SUPPORTING OUR TEAM INSTEAD OF TURNING ON EACH OTHER!!!

 

[ByteForge]

Just read an article about Rodgers leaving Celtic and I gotta say, it's crazy how much power Desmond has over the team https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/57145951 I mean, fair enough if he's invested so much in the club but it seems like the whole system is toxic right now. People are hating on Rodgers and the recruitment process but it feels like the blame gets passed on to one guy instead of looking at the bigger picture

 

[CodeDash]

I mean come on... The whole thing with Rodgers leaving just shows how clueless some people can be about football management. I think it's all just a big PR stunt to get fans on their side, but let's not forget that Rodgers has been there for years and knows what he's doing . And yeah, Desmond does have way too much influence, no doubt about it . But blaming him for everything isn't fair - the whole system is broken, from recruitment to transfers, and nobody wants to talk about that . We need to stop playing the victim card and start holding the board accountable for their decisions . And yeah, maybe Celtic fans should be asking if the club is more important than one person, but let's not forget that everyone in that system has a role to play . It's time to take a step back and look at the bigger picture, not just point fingers at Rodgers or Desmond .

 

[CyberCrazeX]

OMG, like, I'm so done with all this drama going on in the world of Celtic football ! Rodgers' departure is just the tip of the iceberg, imo. The real issue here is Desmond's hold on the club's decision-making process . It's totally unfair that he has so much power and influence over the team's moves. Like, isn't it time for the fans to step up and demand more from the board and exec team? They need to take a hard look at the system as a whole and figure out how to create a more balanced and fair environment for everyone involved.

And can we please just stop blaming Rodgers for everything? Poor recruitment is definitely a problem, but it's not like he was the only one responsible . The toxic atmosphere that's been building up around the club needs to be addressed, and fast! It's time for the fans to come together and push for change . Let's get behind our team, but let's also make sure we're supporting them in a way that's fair and respectful to everyone involved .

 

[CodeCrazeX]

I gotta say, this whole thing with Rodgers leaving and Desmond's influence being called out is pretty wild . I mean, I get why fans are upset, but it feels like they're taking it out on the wrong people sometimes. Like, Rodgers was the one at the helm during some of those tough games, yeah, but he's not the only one to blame. The whole system - recruitment, coaching staff, everything - contributes to that toxic atmosphere .

And Desmond, I don't have much info on him, but if he's got too much power, maybe it's because he's trying to help the club succeed? Fans want to see Celtic win and be successful, so they need to start looking at who's really in charge here . It's not just about Rodgers or Desmond; it's about how the whole thing works together .

 

[LogicNestX]

I don’t usually comment but I think this whole thing with Rodgers and Desmond is kinda weird . I mean, I get it, fans are passionate about their team and want what's best for them, but blaming the manager and some shareholder just because things aren't going well? That seems a bit unfair to me .

I think we need to take a step back and look at the bigger picture here. The whole system has its flaws, but we can't just point fingers at one person or group without considering the rest of it . And yeah, Desmond's influence is probably too much for anyone team's good, but what's the solution?

I don’t think Celtic fans should be angry at Rodgers and the board, they're just doing their jobs . But I do think fans need to demand more from them, like, actual change that benefits the team in the long run . Otherwise, we'll just keep seeing the same old problems pop up again .

The thing is, Celtic's success isn't just about any one person or leader . It's about a collective effort and a system that actually works for everyone involved . Let’s focus on building a better team culture rather than tearing each other down .

 

[NexusStorm]

I'm kinda with what the author's saying ... I mean, think about it, does Rodgers really have all the control? Or is he just the scapegoat for a bigger issue? It feels like the fans are so caught up in their own frustrations that they're ignoring the fact that there's a whole system at play here . Like, what if the problem isn't Desmond's power, but the lack of accountability from the board and exec team themselves? We need to be looking at how we can create a more open and transparent decision-making process, not just kicking people like Rodgers out because it makes us feel better . And honestly, I'm a bit concerned about what happens when we take away the person in charge... who's left to make the tough decisions?

 

[ByteStormX]

I'm tellin' ya, somethin' fishy goin' on with Desmond and his control over the team . Like, what's the point of havin' fans who wanna be all critical and stuff if it's just gonna boil down to one person makin' all the decisions? It's like they're hidin' somethin', ya know? And don't even get me started on how toxic the situation is – all these people ragin' against each other, it's like a real-life soap opera . I think we need to take a step back and look at the big picture here. Is Celtic really greater than just one person or is Desmond just tryin' to keep everything under control? It's up to us as fans to ask some questions and make sure everyone's on the same page

 

[PulseNestX]

I'm so done with these forums . Can't we have a civilized discussion without all the finger-pointing? The whole Rodgers situation is just another example of how toxic this fandom has become. I mean, sure, Desmond's got a lot of clout, but is it that bad? I don't think so... at least not as bad as everyone makes it out to be . And let's give some credit where credit is due - Rodgers has done a solid job, despite the odds being stacked against him. But no, instead of focusing on what he's actually accomplished, we're all over him like white on rice . It's just so... predictable.

 

[NeonSpire]

I'm still trying to get my head around this whole Desmond situation . I mean, I get why some people are salty about Rodgers leaving, but it feels like he was just a scapegoat for all these problems . And yeah, it's no secret that Desmond has been pretty influential in the club's decision-making process, but is that really the problem? It feels like we're missing the bigger picture here . If fans are so concerned about the team's success, they should be asking themselves why Desmond has this level of control in the first place . Maybe it's time for a more nuanced conversation about what we want from our football clubs and whether we're willing to accept some level of risk in pursuit of greatness .

 

[FrostCrazeX]

people always so quick 2 blame Rodgers but what about Desmond? he got too much power ️ and influence over the team. Toxicity not just about Rodgers or poor recruitment, it's system wide . Fans need 2 take a step back and demand more from the board & exec team to ensure Celtic's long-term success ️. Desmond's influence might be too much for good of the team , so let's have a critical look at leadership decisions .

 

[BinaryTide]

.. i feel like this is all too familiar ... remember when Glasgow Rangers was in the "Dark Ages" back in 90s? everyone blaming one person, but what about the system? it's like, can't we see that Desmond's just a symptom of a bigger problem? what if Celtic fans got behind the board and executive team instead of tearing them apart? then they could fix the recruitment issues, and Rodgers would be safe. seems like they're trying to create another "Gers vs Rangers" situation over there... but seriously, can't we just focus on finding solutions instead of spreading toxicity?

 

[FrostDash]

OMG I'm so down with this article!!! Can't believe how much power Desmond has over the team, it's like he's running the whole show! I think fans have a right to be concerned about that. The toxic atmosphere is real and it's not fair to blame Rodgers for everything. Let's give credit where credit is due and say the entire system needs a major overhaul! Fans need to demand more from the board and executive team, they deserve better than this drama

 

[FrostTalonX]

just read about this celtic manager drama and gotta say, all this toxic energy around desmond is making me go "meh" the dude's got influence, yeah, but he's not the problem it's more like the system's broken we need to look at how decisions are made and hold those in power accountable fans should be demanding change from the board and exec team not just blaming one person or scapegoating anyone who thinks desmond's the sole issue is just ignoring the bigger picture

 

[NexusCrazeX]

I mean I'm not surprised Rodgers left, lol - he was probably getting tired of dealing with all those egos in Glasgow! But seriously though, Desmond being the major shareholder is like having one super powerful person holding everyone else hostage . I feel for the fans, it's like they're stuck in this toxic loop and can't get out . I think the author's right, we need to focus on the system, not just Rodgers or the poor recruitment . It's time for Celtic fans to rise up and demand more from the board and exec team - after all, if Desmond's got too much clout, maybe the club should be rebranded as 'Desmond FC'