Elgar: The Dream of Gerontius album review – Gardner and the LPO's reading is bold and dramatic

Edward Gardner brings a vibrant energy to his new recording of Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius, infusing the iconic choral work with an operatic sense of drama and urgency. Recorded live at the 2022 BBC Proms, this performance is marked by outstanding vocal performances from Allan Clayton and Jamie Barton, who bring depth and nuance to their respective roles.

Clayton's portrayal of the dying man is particularly striking, conveying a sense of febrile terror that is both thrilling and heart-wrenching. His heroic tone in Sanctus Fortis is a highlight of the recording, while Barton's luxurious mezzo-soprano provides a rich tapestry of emotion throughout. James Platt's craggy bass brings gravity to his role as the Angel of the Agony.

Gardner's conducting is equally impressive, imbuing the work with an almost operatic boldness that propels the music forward with momentum. The combined forces of the London Philharmonic and Hallé choirs add a sense of drama and tension to the performance, conjuring up a chorus of demons at their heels.

If there's a drawback to this recording it's that the acoustic occasionally robs the sound of its last ounce of immediacy. However, this is a minor quibble in what is otherwise an outstanding achievement. Gardner's The Dream of Gerontius ranks alongside another notable release by Nicholas Collon earlier this year, and is sure to delight fans of Elgar's masterpiece.
 
🌸 I'm totally obsessed with classical music lately! 🎶 This new recording of Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius is absolutely stunning! Edward Gardner really knows how to bring out the drama and emotion in the piece - it's like you're right there with Allan Clayton as he's experiencing his last moments. 💔 And can we talk about Jamie Barton's vocals? She's literally giving me all the feels every time she sings! 😭 James Platt's bass is so powerful too, adds this whole new level of depth to the performance. 🎶 The only thing I'd say is that sometimes it sounds a bit muffled in certain parts, but overall it's like they're just trying to be perfect and I appreciate that 💯
 
omg u guys have 2 hear this new recording of elgars the dream of gerontius its literally amazing edward gardner does an insane job conducting & brings so much drama to the performance Allan clayton as the dying man is low key giving me all the feels his vocals r like wow james platt's bass voice tho i love it but kinda wish there wud be more live sound in this recording can hear some of the instruments a lil too muddy
 
lol I mean, can you believe how much emotion these singers bring to the table? 🤩 Allan Clayton's performance in Sanctus Fortis had me on the edge of my seat, his voice is like butter smooth but with just the right amount of grit to make it feel real 💔. And James Platt's bass is like the heartbeat of the piece, it's so grounding. But I do think they could've done a better job capturing the raw emotion in some of the quieter moments 🎧💫
 
I'm loving this new recording of Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius 🎵😍! Edward Gardner really knows how to bring the drama out in this piece. Those soloists are on point too - Allan Clayton's performance as the dying man is giving me chills every time 😱. And James Platt, his bass is so rich and deep it's like the angel of agony himself 🙏.

I think what I love most about this recording is how Gardner balances the different moods in the piece. It's not just a pretty sound, it's got real tension and urgency to it. The choirs are amazing too - they really add to the sense of drama. My only minor gripe is that sometimes it feels like the acoustic is taking away some of the sharpness. But honestly, that's a small price to pay for this kind of music 🙌. I'm defo going to be listening to this one again and again 👍
 
🎶 I'm loving the new recording of Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius! Edward Gardner really brings out the drama in that piece - it's like you can feel the urgency 🕰️. The vocals from Allan Clayton and Jamie Barton are insane, they're like two powerful instruments 🎸. And James Platt's bass is so deep and rich, it gives me chills every time 😱. I mean, what's not to love about a recording that makes you feel all the emotions? It's like you're right there with the characters, experiencing their pain and fear alongside them 🤕. My only minor complaint would be that sometimes it feels a bit... distant? Like, I can hear the instruments, but they're not quite as close to me as I'd like 😐. Still, that's a small price to pay for an album that's this good! 👏
 
Back
Top