New York Governor Kathy Hochul has refused to increase congestion tolls in Manhattan during the holiday season despite the potential to ease traffic. The state law gives the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) the power to raise daily congestion tolls by 25% on "Gridlock Alert" days, but Hochul's office has blocked this plan.
The MTA collects nearly $2 million each day from congestion tolls, which is used to finance major upgrades to its aging transit infrastructure. However, without the toll increase, the agency will not be able to meet its financial obligations.
Critics of Hochul's decision say that it's a missed opportunity to reduce traffic and improve public transportation in the city. "The system we have right now is what I'd call a dumb system... It's a binary system," said Sam Schwartz, a prominent transit planner. He advocates for a more sophisticated congestion pricing system that charges people based on how much of the central business district they use.
Hochul's decision has been met with frustration from pro-transit groups who argue that the MTA should take bold action to address traffic congestion rather than just making minor adjustments. Danny Pearlstein, of Riders Alliance, said, "Gridlock alert days should come with meaningful action, not just a gentle nudge."
Economists also warn that imposing extra fees on drivers during the holiday season is unlikely to be effective and may alienate suburban voters who are already opposed to congestion pricing.
The MTA has approved a plan to increase tolls to $15 in 2031. However, Hochul has not increased prices temporarily, even as the agency struggles to meet its financial obligations. The Governor's decision has sparked debate over how to address traffic congestion and improve public transportation in New York City.
The MTA collects nearly $2 million each day from congestion tolls, which is used to finance major upgrades to its aging transit infrastructure. However, without the toll increase, the agency will not be able to meet its financial obligations.
Critics of Hochul's decision say that it's a missed opportunity to reduce traffic and improve public transportation in the city. "The system we have right now is what I'd call a dumb system... It's a binary system," said Sam Schwartz, a prominent transit planner. He advocates for a more sophisticated congestion pricing system that charges people based on how much of the central business district they use.
Hochul's decision has been met with frustration from pro-transit groups who argue that the MTA should take bold action to address traffic congestion rather than just making minor adjustments. Danny Pearlstein, of Riders Alliance, said, "Gridlock alert days should come with meaningful action, not just a gentle nudge."
Economists also warn that imposing extra fees on drivers during the holiday season is unlikely to be effective and may alienate suburban voters who are already opposed to congestion pricing.
The MTA has approved a plan to increase tolls to $15 in 2031. However, Hochul has not increased prices temporarily, even as the agency struggles to meet its financial obligations. The Governor's decision has sparked debate over how to address traffic congestion and improve public transportation in New York City.
I'm all for improving our public transit system, but come on Kathy Hochul 
... increasing tolls is just a temporary band-aid solution. It's gonna drive more people outta the city during the holidays and clog up the roads even worse! 
The MTA needs to think outside the box here, implement some fancy smart traffic management systems or revamp our parking policies for real. This 25% increase is just a nice-to-have, not a must-have 
. What's the point of increasing tolls if we're not gonna make any actual changes to our infrastructure? It's like throwing money at the problem instead of solving it 
. We need some bold action here, not just a gentle nudge 
I mean, come on! Kathy Hochul is being super shortsighted here. She's basically saying "nope" to the MTA increasing tolls during peak season just because it's the holidays. I get that she doesn't want to alienate suburban voters, but what about the rest of us who use public transportation daily? It's a classic case of short-term thinking vs long-term problem-solving.
. And let's be real, who doesn't love the idea of a stress-free commute during the holidays? 
I'm all for the idea of charging people based on how much they use the central business district - that sounds like a no-brainer to me 
. It's just frustrating when you see so many pro-transit groups and experts speaking out against this common-sense solution, while Hochul's office is more concerned with making sure everyone loves her 
I think it's interesting that Hochul is hesitant to implement a temporary toll increase during the holiday season, despite the MTA's financial struggles. While it might seem like a no-brainer to raise fees when revenue is low, economists are right to warn about the potential backlash from suburban voters who may already be opposed to congestion pricing in general.
. The fact that Hochul's office blocked this plan suggests that there's still a lot of work to be done to find ways to improve public transportation without alienating certain groups.
.
! The Riders Alliance is totally on point with their argument - what's the point of making incremental changes when we should be going all-in? 
On the other hand, not increasing tolls could lead to a bunch of bureaucratic red tape and might not even address the root cause of the problem.
And honestly, if Danny Pearlstein and Riders Alliance are going crazy about it, that's a good thing - we need more people speaking up on this issue! 
. I mean, we all know how crazy traffic gets during the holidays, right? 
It'd be awesome to see some real solutions instead of just playing around with prices 
The MTA needs that cash to upgrade their infrastructure, and if they don't get it, we'll just keep struggling with traffic jams 
. It's time for some bold moves from the Governor, stat! 
- so Hochul is refusing to increase tolls in Manhattan during the holiday season? Like what a waste of an opportunity 
. I mean, you can already see how much traffic congestion is a problem and this is just gonna make it worse 
.
Interesting how pro-transit groups are calling for more action, like a sophisticated congestion pricing system, while economists warn that this holiday season's toll hikes might be a waste of time 
. It's not just about throwing more money at the problem (although, $2 million a day isn't bad 
. But we need to be careful not to alienate people who are already skeptical of congestion pricing 
, can't believe Kathy Hochul is blocking that toll hike 
with no cash to upgrade those ancient trains 
and people are still complaining about the holiday season gridlock 
. Sam Schwartz makes some sense 
about that dumb system they got now, but it sounds like the MTA's too chicken to take on the big boys 
. They know congestion pricing would help, but they're too scared to take the leap 
.
.