Keira Knightley's Christmas ad for Waitrose has left many people feeling warm and fuzzy inside, but let's not get ahead of ourselves - it's only the first time we've seen this romcom. While Knightley is undoubtedly the star of the show, her performance in a four-minute romcom about biscuits that closely resemble Joe Wilkinson's face is impressive. The plot, which sees Knightley play a charming Waitrose employee who falls for Wilkinson's character, is undeniably sweet and funny.
However, it's worth noting that this type of ad will likely be seen dozens of times over the next six weeks - an unrelenting loop of Love Actually-style romcoms designed to break our spirits into shopping at Christmas. At first, Knightley's appearance in the advert feels like a comforting return to her romcom roots. It's as if we're watching someone do something they've tried to distance themselves from for years, and that's certainly enjoyable.
But let's not get too caught up in nostalgia - this type of ad is technically an industry first. The fact that it references old romcom tropes without being too obvious suggests a level of cleverness on the part of the writers. And while it's true that you've probably seen Love Actually dozens of times before, watching it on repeat over a six-week period would be a whole different story.
The real challenge lies in avoiding this type of ad at all costs - imagine having to watch an important documentary, only to have it interrupted by Love Actually. It's a scenario that's both absurd and terrifying. For now, Knightley's Waitrose advert is lovely, but ask me about my opinion six weeks from now, and I suspect I'll be feeling differently.
Ultimately, the key to watching this type of ad without losing your mind lies in its ability to balance warmth and humor with repetition and familiarity. While it may not be perfect, the advert does feel like a genuine attempt to make us smile during the holiday season - even if it is technically an industry first that will no doubt become a chore to watch over time.
However, it's worth noting that this type of ad will likely be seen dozens of times over the next six weeks - an unrelenting loop of Love Actually-style romcoms designed to break our spirits into shopping at Christmas. At first, Knightley's appearance in the advert feels like a comforting return to her romcom roots. It's as if we're watching someone do something they've tried to distance themselves from for years, and that's certainly enjoyable.
But let's not get too caught up in nostalgia - this type of ad is technically an industry first. The fact that it references old romcom tropes without being too obvious suggests a level of cleverness on the part of the writers. And while it's true that you've probably seen Love Actually dozens of times before, watching it on repeat over a six-week period would be a whole different story.
The real challenge lies in avoiding this type of ad at all costs - imagine having to watch an important documentary, only to have it interrupted by Love Actually. It's a scenario that's both absurd and terrifying. For now, Knightley's Waitrose advert is lovely, but ask me about my opinion six weeks from now, and I suspect I'll be feeling differently.
Ultimately, the key to watching this type of ad without losing your mind lies in its ability to balance warmth and humor with repetition and familiarity. While it may not be perfect, the advert does feel like a genuine attempt to make us smile during the holiday season - even if it is technically an industry first that will no doubt become a chore to watch over time.