If geoengineering is ever deployed in a climate emergency, transparency is key | Ines Camilloni

Climate Crisis Looms Large: Why Transparency Matters in Geoengineering Discussions

The world teeters on the edge, with critical threshold levels or tipping points soon to be reached due to the escalating climate crisis. Amidst this precarious situation, a potentially game-changing yet contentious proposal has gained traction: solar geoengineering – deliberate reflection of sunlight to cool the planet. Proponents believe it could provide a much-needed reprieve by buying us time, while critics warn of uncharted risks.

The scientific community is making strides in researching solar geoengineering, with techniques like stratospheric aerosol injection and marine cloud brightening being explored. However, these technologies have yet to receive significant attention from policymakers in the global south. This oversight must be rectified – and fast.

Climate change has disproportionately affected the global south, where rising temperatures, extreme weather events, and altered precipitation patterns pose significant challenges to health, food, water security, and economic development. As solar geoengineering's effects would be unevenly distributed across regions, inclusive research is crucial to determine who would benefit and who might suffer adverse consequences.

Governments in the global south are grappling with tough questions, as they have largely remained silent on solar geoengineering due to limited research funding and scarce public debate. The absence of meaningful involvement risks perpetuating colonial dynamics that have historically shaped climate policy – solutions created for us but not by us.

However, there are signs of constructive change emerging. Initiatives like the Degrees Initiative are supporting scientists from the global south to study solar geoengineering's impact on their regions. While these efforts are a step in the right direction, they remain under-resourced and need further support.

The solution lies in public research led by institutions in the global south, with funding that promotes south-south collaboration and a robust global governance framework ensuring equity, transparency, and informed consent. Critical engagement is not about endorsing or rejecting solar geoengineering but about empowering ourselves to ask tough questions, assess potential benefits and risks, and participate meaningfully in policy discussions rooted in local realities.

Ultimately, solar geoengineering is just one aspect of the climate crisis puzzle – a temporary fix at best. The real challenge lies in correcting generations of polluting and ensuring a sustainable future. Any discussion about its deployment must be transparent and inclusive, with climate justice demanding that such an effort be debated openly.
 
I'm really skeptical about this solar geoengineering thing 🤔. It sounds like a Band-Aid solution to me. We need to address the root cause of climate change, not just try to patch it up with some fancy tech. What if we're messing with the planet's ecosystem in ways we can't even imagine? We've got scientists from the global south trying to get involved, but they need more funding and resources 🤑. Can't we just support research on sustainable energy sources instead? That's the real fix 💡. And what about the unequal distribution of benefits? Some regions will be fine, while others are already struggling to survive 😩. We need transparency and inclusivity in climate policy, not some half-baked solution that might just make things worse 🚨.
 
OMG u guys I'm literally freaking out about this geoengineering thing 🤯 it's like we're running out of options to save the planet and now there's this proposal to just reflect sunlight or whatever lol idk if it sounds too good to be true but at least it's worth exploring, right? The thing is tho I've been reading about climate change nonstop since my mom got us solar panels last year 🌞 and honestly it's so hard to see how some regions are gonna get hit way harder than others. Like what even is fair about that? we gotta make sure anyone who gets 'saved' by geoengineering also considers the potential consequences for ppl in other places, right? I mean it's not just about science & policy tho it's like our future depends on it 🌎
 
Ugh, climate crisis is getting super scary 🌪️... I just hope they figure out something to save the planet cuz solar geoengineering sounds like it could be our only hope at this point 💡. I mean, why are governments in the global south being left out of these discussions? It's not fair that they're already struggling with climate change and now we're expecting them to solve the whole thing too 😩. We need to get more research done and make sure it's accessible to everyone, especially those who are getting hit the hardest by climate change 💕. I'm all for transparency and inclusivity in this conversation - it's not just about solar geoengineering, it's about making a sustainable future for everyone 🌎!
 
I'm low-key worried about this solar geoengineering thing 🌪️. I mean, on one hand, it's like, super desperate times, we gotta do something, right? But at the same time, I think we need to take a step back and make sure we're not just rushing into something that could have major unintended consequences 🤯.

I'm all for transparency and inclusivity in policy discussions – it's like, super important that we involve scientists from the global south in these conversations, 'cause they're the ones who are most affected by climate change, you know? 💡

But at the same time, I think we need to be careful not to recreate old colonial dynamics 🤔. We can't just let rich countries come up with solutions for everyone else without any input or consideration – that's just not cool 😒.

I guess what I'm saying is, we gotta make sure we're having this conversation in a way that prioritizes equity and justice 💖. It's not about whether solar geoengineering is a good idea or not – it's about how we approach it in a way that actually benefits everyone 🌎.
 
I'm so done with how geoengineering discussions are being handled 🙄. It's all about the North getting to decide what's best for everyone else without considering the devastating impact it could have on vulnerable communities in the South. We need transparency and inclusive research ASAP 🕒. The fact that institutions in the global South aren't getting enough funding is a huge red flag ⚠️. Can't we just support scientists from our own regions to study this stuff without having to beg for resources? It's time for real south-south collaboration 💪. Anything less feels like more of the same colonial climate policy that's been screwing us over for too long 🤦‍♀️.
 
Ugh man, the thought of messing around with our planet's temperature is just wild 🤯. I mean, I get it, we gotta do something or else we're toast 😨. But have you seen some of these geoengineering plans? It sounds like a sci-fi movie 🚀. Like, injecting aerosols into space and brightening marine clouds? Sounds like some crazy stuff 🔥.

And don't even get me started on the equity thing 🤝. I mean, we're already talking about colonizing climate policy for the global south. That's messed up 🙅‍♂️. We gotta make sure that whoever gets to benefit from these geoengineering plans also has a say in how they're implemented 💬.

I'm all for public research and transparency, but let's be real – we've been trying to solve this climate crisis with piecemeal solutions for decades 🕰️. It's time to get serious about addressing the root causes of pollution and making sustainable changes that benefit everyone 🌎. Solar geoengineering might be a temporary fix, but it's not gonna cut it if we don't tackle the real issues 🔨.

Anyway, I guess what I'm trying to say is – let's keep an open mind, but also keep our feet on the ground 🙏. We need to make sure that any solution we come up with is equitable, sustainable, and actually helps us solve this crisis 🌟. Anything less would be a waste of time ⏰.
 
🌎 we need to rethink our approach to solving the climate crisis, can't just slapband a quick fix like geoengineering without considering the longterm consequences for ppl in the global south 👀 gotta prioritize transparency & research that's led by ppl from those regions themselves 💡 not some developed country's idea of what's best for everyone 🤝
 
idk why people are so hyped about solar geoengineering 🤔. like, it's not gonna magically solve our problems. we need to focus on reducing emissions and transitioning to renewable energy ASAP. all this talk about buying us time is just delaying the inevitable. we should be investing in research that actually helps us adapt to climate change, not trying to fix it with some high-tech Band-Aid 🌳. and what's with all these exclusive initiatives for scientists from the global south? can't we get more funding for basic research and education instead of playing favorites among countries? transparency is key, but it's gotta be more than just tokenistic gestures 💸.
 
im thinking this whole geoengineering thing is like trying to put out fires with fire 🔥... dont get me wrong its worth exploring but we need to make sure we're not just kicking the can down the road and making things worse in the long run 🤔
 
I'm like totally stoked that there are people working on finding solutions to the climate crisis 🌞! I mean, solar geoengineering is a wild idea, but it's crazy to think about how much of a difference it could make if done right. The problem is, we need more transparency and inclusivity in these discussions - like, who gets to decide what happens to our planet? Not just the rich countries, you know? We need scientists from the global south at the table, with proper funding and support 🤝. It's all about equity and fairness, you feel me? And let's not forget, solar geoengineering is just a Band-Aid on a much bigger wound - we gotta address the root causes of pollution and climate change for real 🔋. But hey, at least there's hope, right? 😊
 
🌎 I mean, come on! We're talking about geoengineering here. It's like playing with fire without knowing the consequences. They need to get the experts from South America, Africa, and Asia involved in the discussions ASAP. Can't just leave it up to Western scientists to decide what's best for us. 🤔 And what about the funding? We can't keep throwing money at a select few when there are more pressing issues like renewable energy and carbon capture tech that could really make a difference. It's all about transparency and accountability, you know? If we don't get it right this time, we'll be facing a whole new set of problems. 🌪️
 
Back
Top