US President Donald Trump's clemency drive has taken another hit as the Justice Department replaced pardons posted online with similar signatures by Trump with new versions featuring distinctly different sign-offs, amid growing scrutiny over the authenticity of his presidential signatures.
A recent batch of pardons granted by Trump to seven individuals, including former New York Mets player Darryl Strawberry and former Tennessee House speaker Glen Casada, raised eyebrows after it emerged that some of the original pardons posted online featured identical copies of Trump's signature. The Justice Department initially attributed the mistake to "technical" errors and staffing issues stemming from the Democrat-led government shutdown.
However, handwriting experts have pointed out the glaring inconsistency, saying no two signatures share identical design features in every aspect. Thomas Vastrick, a Florida-based expert who heads the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, described the issue as straightforward, stating that Trump's use of an autopen to sign pardons is not a legitimate reason for questioning their authenticity.
The controversy over Trump's presidential signatures comes amid a flurry of clemency orders issued by his administration. Critics have seized on these issues to undermine what they see as Biden's questionable practice of using the autopen to sign executive actions, claiming it raises questions about his mental faculties and authority.
While some have defended Trump's use of an autopen as legitimate, others argue that he is simply trying to avoid comparison with Biden. Frank Bowman, a legal historian and professor emeritus at the University of Missouri School of Law, said any re-signing of pardons was "an obvious effort to avoid comparison" and "silly".
The issue has sparked renewed tensions between Trump's administration and Democrats in Congress, who have repeatedly criticized Biden's use of the autopen. The White House has insisted that Trump signed all pardons personally, but officials have struggled to explain why similar signatures appear on some online versions.
In a broader context, the ongoing controversy highlights deep divisions over how presidential authority should be exercised. As one Democrat pointed out, it is unclear who ultimately controls the White House and makes executive decisions β or whether there has been any concerted effort to undermine Biden's legitimacy in office.
A recent batch of pardons granted by Trump to seven individuals, including former New York Mets player Darryl Strawberry and former Tennessee House speaker Glen Casada, raised eyebrows after it emerged that some of the original pardons posted online featured identical copies of Trump's signature. The Justice Department initially attributed the mistake to "technical" errors and staffing issues stemming from the Democrat-led government shutdown.
However, handwriting experts have pointed out the glaring inconsistency, saying no two signatures share identical design features in every aspect. Thomas Vastrick, a Florida-based expert who heads the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, described the issue as straightforward, stating that Trump's use of an autopen to sign pardons is not a legitimate reason for questioning their authenticity.
The controversy over Trump's presidential signatures comes amid a flurry of clemency orders issued by his administration. Critics have seized on these issues to undermine what they see as Biden's questionable practice of using the autopen to sign executive actions, claiming it raises questions about his mental faculties and authority.
While some have defended Trump's use of an autopen as legitimate, others argue that he is simply trying to avoid comparison with Biden. Frank Bowman, a legal historian and professor emeritus at the University of Missouri School of Law, said any re-signing of pardons was "an obvious effort to avoid comparison" and "silly".
The issue has sparked renewed tensions between Trump's administration and Democrats in Congress, who have repeatedly criticized Biden's use of the autopen. The White House has insisted that Trump signed all pardons personally, but officials have struggled to explain why similar signatures appear on some online versions.
In a broader context, the ongoing controversy highlights deep divisions over how presidential authority should be exercised. As one Democrat pointed out, it is unclear who ultimately controls the White House and makes executive decisions β or whether there has been any concerted effort to undermine Biden's legitimacy in office.