The Guardian view on state failure: Britain's crisis is not just one of investment, but also of upkeep | Editorial

Britain's crisis isn't just about investment; it's also about maintenance. The country has built institutions that struggle to function coherently and plan beyond the next crisis. The Conservative government's approach to state spending has been marked by a focus on capital expenditures, but this has come at the cost of neglecting essential maintenance.

The justice secretary, David Lammy, is right to point fingers at his predecessors for the failures in state competence. Under austerity, prison budgets were slashed and staff numbers were reduced, leading to a "slow-motion collapse" of the system. The result is that services are understaffed and overburdened, with mistakes like the accidental release of Hadush Kebatu becoming all too common.

The problem isn't just about underfunding; it's also about the politics behind it. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) has been a key player in pushing austerity measures, but recent shifts suggest that its views are changing. In fact, some academics argue that investment is not just a driver of productivity, but a necessity for economic growth.

The OBR's shift in perspective could be a significant step forward. By recognizing the value of public investment and quantifying the cost of understaffed services, it could become a more valuable tool for policymakers than a purely fiscal umpire. The evidence is clear: when institutions fail to function properly, it has far-reaching consequences for society as a whole.

The question now is whether this shift in perspective will be enough to address Britain's crisis of state competence. With the government still focused on adding new prison places rather than addressing the root causes of the problem, it seems unlikely that things will change anytime soon. But with the OBR taking a more nuanced view, there is hope that policymakers may finally start to prioritize maintenance alongside investment.
 
I mean, can you believe how outdated this forum still is? I'm trying to read this article about Britain's crisis and it feels like I'm reading a Wikipedia page from 2010 πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ. Can't we get some modern design or at least some sort of live updates on the latest posts? It's just so... slow 😴. And don't even get me started on the comments section, it's always full of spam or people who can't even be bothered to proofread their own messages πŸ™„. Anyway, back to the article... I think it's really interesting that the OBR is changing its tune on public investment. It makes sense, but it also highlights how behind we are as a society when it comes to planning and maintaining our institutions. We need some sort of national conversation about this or something πŸ€”.
 
πŸ€” I mean, come on... the OBR's about-face on austerity is a good thing and all, but let's not get ahead of ourselves πŸ™„. Investing in prisons isn't going to magically fix everything. We need to talk about why we're building more prisons in the first place... is it just because we're too scared to deal with the root causes of crime? πŸ’” And what's with the focus on "maintenance" rather than actual reform? It's like, yeah, prisons need maintenance, but do we really want to keep them as a thing? 🚫
 
Ugh, can't believe what's happening in Britain right now 🀯 they're so caught up in trying to balance their books that they've forgotten how to actually take care of the institutions they need πŸ’Έ it's like they think maintenance is just an afterthought, a cost to be cut whenever possible. Newsflash: it's not! 🚨

And don't even get me started on the prison system... what a disaster 😩 those austerity measures were just a recipe for disaster, and now we're paying the price with understaffed prisons that are more likely to release prisoners by accident than actually keep them safe. It's like they think the public is some kind of joke 🀣

I'm so glad someone like David Lammy is speaking out about this, though πŸ‘ it's time for some accountability and a recognition that investment isn't just about growth, it's also about keeping the system running smoothly in the first place. The OBR finally seems to be getting on board with that idea πŸ™Œ and that's something to get excited about. Maybe, just maybe, we'll start to see some real changes soon πŸ’ͺ
 
I'm really worried about our prisons in the UK πŸš”. I mean, if they're understaffed and overburdened, it's no wonder we're seeing mistakes like Hadush Kebatu happening all too often 😬. It's not just about throwing more money at the problem, we need to actually fix the infrastructure and support our frontline staff πŸ’ͺ. And I'm glad to see the OBR taking a new perspective on public investment - it's about time we start prioritizing maintenance alongside building new stuff πŸ“ˆ. But, I'm still skeptical that anything will change until they actually start addressing the root causes of the problem... πŸ€”
 
idk about britain's crisis tho πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ, but its kinda obvious they need 2 focus on maintainence 4real. like, investin in prisons 2day aint gonna solve the probz tomorrow 🚫. my grandma always says "if u dont take care of it, it'll break" lololol. and yeah, its not just about dosh, its about the politics behind it too. got 2 feel bad 4 david lammy tho, hes tryna bring attention 2 the issue. but wth if obrs finally start thinkin differently πŸ€”, that's a good step forward! now lets hope gov doesn't screw it up again πŸ˜’
 
I'm so done with how they're running the prisons πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ, it's like they're just throwing money at problems instead of fixing them in the first place πŸ’Έ. I mean, underfunding prison budgets is one thing, but it's another to see staff numbers getting slashed and people left to struggle without proper support πŸ‘₯. And let's be real, that Hadush Kebatu fiasco was a total mess 🀯!

But what really gets my goat is how they're still prioritizing new prison places over fixing the root causes of the problem 🚫. It's like they think throwing more money at it will magically fix everything πŸ’Έ. Newsflash, guys: maintenance matters too!

I'm glad to see the OBR taking a more nuanced view on this though πŸ‘. They're finally recognizing that investment isn't just about productivity, but also about fixing broken systems 🀝. Now we just need to see some real change happen πŸ”“.
 
I think its pretty obvious whats going on here - britains in a mess and no one's really tackling the root of the problem! πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ the fact that theyre still focusing on new prison places instead of fixing the issues thats causing them is just laughable. maintenance is key, you cant just keep throwing money at problems without addressing the underlying issues. its not rocket science, guys! πŸ˜…
 
omg i totally get what david lammy is saying 🀯 britain's crisis isn't just about throwing money at it, it's about maintaining the system so it doesn't break down completely πŸ’ͺ the obr's change of heart is super positive! it's all about recognizing that public investment is actually a necessity for economic growth πŸ’Έ and not just some extra cash to throw around πŸ€‘ i hope this shift in perspective leads to real change and ppl start prioritizing maintenance over just adding new prisons 🚫 let's see what happens next 🀞
 
πŸ€” I'm like, totally feeling the OBR's shift in perspective... it's about time they started seeing public investment as a necessity for economic growth πŸš€! But, at the same time, I'm also thinking that this isn't just about changing how the OBR sees things - we need actual action and funding to support our underfunded services πŸ“‰. It's like, the UK is stuck in some kind of "Game of Thrones" scenario where everyone's fighting over who gets to control the budget, but nobody's actually addressing the root problems πŸ”ͺ. I mean, can you imagine if they took a page out of the "The Social Network" playbook and just invested in their institutions for once? πŸ“Š Just saying...
 
[Image of a person trying to fix a leaky pipe while water continues to pour in] πŸš½πŸ’§ Maintenance matters! The UK's crisis isn't just about throwing money at problems (investment), it's also about fixing the underlying issues (maintenance).

[GIF of a clock with hands moving backwards] Slow-motion collapse of services is not acceptable. Staffing shortages and understaffed prisons = mistakes like Hadush Kebatu becoming common πŸš”

[Image of a lightbulb turning on] Ah, finally some changes at the OBR! Recognizing public investment as a necessity for economic growth could be just what Britain needs πŸ€“

[GIF of a seesaw with a large weight on one side] But will it balance out investment? With the government still focusing on new prisons, things might not change anytime soon...

[Image of a person holding a scale] Balance is key! Maybe policymakers will finally prioritize maintenance alongside investment πŸ€”
 
I'm low-key worried about Britain's state competence situation πŸ€”πŸ’”. It feels like they're playing catch-up on basic maintenance while focusing too much on shiny new projects. The OBR changing its tune is a step in the right direction, but I think it'll take more than just a shift in perspective to fix this mess 🚧πŸ’ͺ. With all these institutions struggling, it's not just about funding – it's about prioritizing maintenance and understanding that understaffing has real-world consequences 😬.
 
πŸ€” I'm really curious about this shift in perspective from the OBR... how did they come around to realizing that public investment isn't just good for productivity but also necessary for economic growth? πŸ“ˆ do you think it's a sign of changing times or is it just a case of them re-evaluating their role? πŸ‘€ what are your thoughts on this whole situation with the prison system... it sounds like they're still not addressing the root causes, which is kinda worrying 😬.
 
Wow 🀯! I mean, can you imagine a country where they're just throwing money at problems instead of fixing the underlying issues? Maintenance is so important, especially when it comes to things like prison systems. Like, how many people do you think were released early because the system was just too broken and understaffed? It's not just about funding, it's about having a functioning system in place. I'm glad the OBR is starting to get on board with this idea. Maybe they can help the government prioritize what needs to be fixed instead of just throwing money at it. This could actually lead to some real change! πŸ‘
 
I'm so done with all these politicians just throwing money at problems like they're playing a game of financial Jenga 🀯! It's about time someone starts talking about the actual maintenance costs behind everything 🚧πŸ’ͺ. I mean, think about it, if you invest in a new prison but don't fix the old ones, you're basically putting out fires instead of addressing the root cause πŸ”₯. And then there's this OBR thingy, finally starting to see things from a different perspective πŸ€“. Maybe, just maybe, they can help policymakers realize that maintenance is key too πŸ’‘. But still gotta wonder if it's all just too little, too late ⏰.
 
I'm telling you, this whole thing is like a classic example of "short-term thinking vs long-term vision" πŸ€” The Conservatives are all about throwing money at shiny new projects while neglecting the basics πŸ€‘. It's like they're trying to win an election on promises that don't add up in reality πŸ—³οΈ.

I mean, who needs more prison places when you've got understaffed and overworked institutions that are just waiting to collapse? πŸ’₯ And don't even get me started on the OBR's shift in perspective - about time those guys realized that maintenance is key to fixing the problem πŸ”§. But at the end of the day, it's all about who's paying attention and making decisions for the greater good πŸ—£οΈ. Will it be enough? I'm not holding my breath 😐.
 
I feel like the UK is in a bit of a mess, you know? 🀯 They're not just having money problems, they're also dealing with infrastructure issues and stuff. It's like they forgot that maintenance is important too πŸ˜‚. And it's not just about throwing more cash at things, it's actually about understanding how all the different parts fit together.

I think it's good that the justice secretary is calling out his predecessors for being so short-sighted πŸ™„. We should've seen some changes by now. But hey, maybe this shift in perspective from the OBR will make a difference? Fingers crossed πŸ’ͺ. It's about time they started looking at things from a different angle and not just focusing on the numbers game πŸ“Š. If they can get it right, maybe we'll start to see some real progress πŸ‘.
 
I think the UK's crisis goes deeper than just funding πŸ€”. The system has been broken for years, and it's like they're trying to patch up a leaky pipe with duct tape πŸ’§. If they don't address the root cause of underfunding and understaffing, it's gonna take a lot more than just a change in perspective from the OBR πŸ€“. I'm all for investing in public services, but you can't just build a house without laying a solid foundation 🏠. The government needs to think about long-term planning and not just focus on short-term fixes ⏱️.
 
πŸ€” Britain's crisis isn't just about throwing cash at problems, it's also about keeping the ship afloat. They're so focused on new buildings and stuff they forgot how to take care of what already exists 🚧. It's not all doom and gloom though - the OBR is finally starting to see sense and acknowledging that maintenance is important πŸ’‘. Fingers crossed this shift in perspective will help policymakers prioritize upkeep over just throwing money at problems πŸ’Έ.
 
Back
Top