The Guardian view on the EU's answer to Trump: trade without threats | Editorial

European Trade Shift a Rebuke to Trump's Tariff Tactics

The EU's recent trade pact with India marks a significant shift in its approach to economic cooperation, one that is starkly at odds with the tactics employed by former US President Donald Trump. Gone are the days of using tariffs as a tool of economic and political compulsion, replaced by a more collaborative and mutually beneficial approach.

While Trump was wont to threaten his trading partners with tariffs, the EU has taken a different tack. The India deal, which saw tariff reductions worth €4bn (£3.5bn), may seem modest in comparison to the €180bn trade relationship between the two sides, but it represents a fundamental change in the EU's approach. Rather than trying to lock Asian partners into fixed industrial roles, the EU is now encouraging them to move up the value chain.

This shift is evident in the EU's deal with Vietnam, which upgrades ties and encourages Hanoi to transition towards high-tech production. In return, India benefits from increased access to European markets, particularly in textiles, without facing onerous demands. The EU, meanwhile, gains access to a new market for goods exports, as well as the opportunity to help Indian firms adopt advanced European technologies.

The key difference between the EU and Trump's approach is one of tone. While the US under Trump used tariffs as a means of exerting influence and dominance, the EU treats trade as a way to share growth and cooperation without demanding submission. The EU also recognizes that coercion can backfire, and has taken steps to preserve policy space for its trading partners.

This new approach represents a rebuke to Trump's tactics, which were seen as heavy-handed and divisive. By contrast, the EU's trade shift is a model of pragmatism and cooperation, one that acknowledges the importance of preserving autonomy while still promoting economic growth and development.

The implications of this shift are far-reaching, particularly in Asia. The EU's deals with India and Vietnam represent a significant departure from its previous approach, which was built around one-way access and managed dependency. Instead, the EU is now encouraging industrial upgrading and selective protection, allowing its trading partners to retain their policy space while still benefiting from increased trade.

This new approach also echoes the idea of middle powers building resilience through interdependence without surrendering autonomy. As Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney once argued, rich countries can promote growth by promoting openness and cooperation with poorer countries. The EU's trade shift is a testament to this idea, one that acknowledges the importance of history and experience in shaping its approach to economic cooperation.
 
Ugh, I'm so over these forum responses being way too long 😩. Can't they just keep it concise? Like, 1-2 paragraphs is all we need. This article about the EU's new trade pact with India and Vietnam is actually pretty interesting, but do we really need a whole essay on it? 🤔

Anyway, I love how the EU is finally taking a more collaborative approach to trade. No more threats of tariffs and coercion like Trump used to do. It's all about mutual benefit and cooperation now. And it makes sense, too - when you give countries policy space to make their own decisions, they're more likely to actually listen to what you have to say.

But still, I wish the EU would be a bit more transparent about its goals and motivations. Like, why did they really want to make this deal with India? Was it just to get them on board or is there something more going on behind the scenes? 🤷‍♂️
 
just read about this deal between EU and India, and i gotta say, it's kinda refreshing to see the EU ditching the whole tariff thing... i mean, trump was all about using tariffs to get what he wanted, but the eu is like "hey, let's work together" 🤝. it makes sense too, because now india gets access to european markets and the eu gets to share some of that growth. but what really caught my attention is how this shift in approach is all about preserving policy space for trading partners... i mean, who wants to be coerced into doing something just so someone else can benefit? 🙅‍♂️
 
I'm so stoked about this new trade deal between the EU and India 🤩! I mean, Trump's whole tariff thing was so last season 🕰️. The EU is finally realizing that just because we're a big player in trade doesn't mean we have to bully everyone else 💸. And can we talk about how cool it is that they're helping Indian firms adopt European tech? That's like, total game-changer for innovation and growth 🔥. I'm also loving the EU's approach of encouraging industrial upgrading rather than just letting countries sit around in a one-way trade deal. It's all about sharing growth and cooperation without being all heavy-handed 💪. This is, like, totally the future of global trade 🌟!
 
omg u cant believe how the EU is totally changing their game now lol they used to be all about tariffs but now its all about sharing growth & cooperation with india 🤝🏽🇮🇳 like what even trump was doing tho? trying to strong-arm everyone into following him 😂 anyway back to the eu - i think this new approach is sooo cool! they're not just imposing their will on other countries but actually listening to them & working together 🤝 it's all about pragmatism & cooperation, not coercion or dominance. and can we talk about how this reflects the whole middle powers building resilience thing? its like, canada did it first now the eu is doing it too 😎
 
🤔 So I'm reading about how the EU just made a big deal with India and it's like totally opposite of what Trump did with tariffs... I mean, I get it, Trump was all about scaring people into doing what he wanted but the EU is more like "hey let's work together" 🤝. And now they're helping India upgrade their industry instead of just taking all their stuff 🚫💸. It's cool to see them treating trade as a way to grow together rather than trying to control each other. And what's up with the difference in tone? The EU is like "let's be friends" while Trump was like "I'm gonna bully you unless you do what I want" 😳. This new approach by the EU is like, totally refreshing and I'm glad they're promoting cooperation over coercion 💪.
 
The EU's new approach to trade is pretty refreshing 🙌. I mean, who needs all that drama and tension when you can just work together? The India deal might seem small, but it shows they're not afraid to take a different path from Trump's US of tariffs. This whole 'upgrading industries' thing sounds like a win-win for everyone involved 💼. And let's be real, the EU's trying to help India grow and stuff, so I reckon it's about time someone showed them some love ❤️.
 
Back
Top