The shameful attacks on the Covid inquiry prove it: the right is lost in anti-science delusion | Polly Toynbee

The Covid Inquiry's damning indictment of Boris Johnson and his ilk has confirmed the right's descent into anti-science delusion. The number 23,000 – the estimated death toll due to Johnson's inaction during the pandemic – will forever be etched into public memory as a stark reminder of the price paid for the UK government's refusal to heed scientific advice.

The right-wing coterie that has dominated the UK media landscape has always had a long history of rejecting life-saving interventions, from seatbelts and smoking restrictions to vaccination and climate action. This creed is now being ruthlessly applied to Covid-19, with lockdowns being portrayed as a "mistake" that has led to economic ruin and the erosion of basic freedoms.

The attacks on the latest Covid inquiry module, chaired by Heather Hallett, are nothing short of shameful. Lockdown sceptics have been quick to contest the report's findings, claiming that lockdowns were pointless and even deadly. The likes of Daniel Hannan and Toby Young have been vocal in their opposition, with some even attempting to outdo each other in their criticism.

But what is disturbingly evident is that this anti-science delusion has become a defining feature of right-wing politics in the UK. Johnson's own remarks about "letting bodies pile high" – which he later denied saying – are a stark illustration of his party's cavalier attitude towards public health and safety.

The real question, however, is whether the cost of lockdowns was worth the lives saved. The answer to this complex equation will depend on one's values and priorities. For bereaved families, the answer is clear: no price can be put on the lives lost during the pandemic. But for policymakers, economists, and politicians, the question requires serious consideration.

The House of Commons library has estimated that the cost of lockdowns could have been as high as £410bn – a staggering sum that would have been better spent on protecting public health and safety. The real test will be how this evidence is used to inform future policy decisions, particularly when it comes to tackling the next pandemic.

One thing is certain: the right's predilection for "freedom" over lifesaving measures must always be confronted truthfully. The notion that sacrificing thousands of lives at the altar of ideology is somehow justified is a false and pernicious narrative that must be exposed for what it is.
 
The Covid inquiry's findings are a stark reminder of the UK government's mishandling of the pandemic. I think its concerning to see how many right-wing politicians have refused to accept scientific evidence, instead relying on ideology and personal opinions. The idea that lockdowns were "pointless" and "deadly" is not only misguided but also potentially deadly in its own right.

I'm not sure if the cost of lockdowns was worth it, but I do know that the lives lost during the pandemic cannot be put into numbers or economic terms. What's more concerning is how this narrative might shape future policy decisions and public health strategies.

The notion of "freedom" being prioritized over public health is a false dichotomy. We need to find a balance between individual freedoms and collective responsibilities, especially when it comes to issues like pandemics. The fact that politicians are willing to gamble with thousands of lives just to prove a point is unsettling.

I hope the Covid inquiry's findings will serve as a wake-up call for policymakers and the public at large. We need to have a more nuanced discussion about the trade-offs between freedoms and public health, and we need it now 🤔
 
omg u cant believe whats happenin in UK rn 🤯 the covid inquiry just dropped this report on govts inaction & its literally devastating 23k ppl lost their lives cuz of boris johnson & co 🤕 they always been anti-science & now its like they think lockdowns r a total waste 😒 i mean wot is wrong with these ppl? cant they jus prioritize lifes over ideology 🙄 its not just about the cost tho, its about all the ppl who got sick or lost loved ones cuz of their actions 💔 and dont even get me started on the sceptics like dan hannan & toby young 🤦‍♂️ they need 2 shut up & listen 2 the science 😒
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around how many lives were lost because of Boris Johnson's decisions during Covid 🤯. It's like, I get it, lockdowns weren't perfect, but 23,000 deaths? That's just heartbreaking 💔. And the fact that some people are still downplaying the impact of lockdowns and trying to shift blame is just infuriating 😡. It's like they're more worried about their precious "freedoms" than actual human lives 🙄.

I remember when I was younger, we used to have those annoying seatbelt rules on buses and trains, but at least that was a small price to pay for not dying in a crash 🚗. Now it seems like the right-wing crowd is trying to deny basic science and common sense, just because it doesn't fit their ideology 🤷‍♂️.

I'm all for public health and safety, but I also think we need to be realistic about the costs of lockdowns. £410bn is a lot of money, but if it saves lives, then so be it 💸. The real question is, how do we balance our desire for freedom with the need to protect people's lives? It's not an easy one, but I think we need to have some tough conversations about this 🤔.
 
Ugh, can't believe how ridiculous the comments on this thread are 🙄. I mean, come on guys, 23,000 dead people? How many times do we have to keep saying that lockdowns saved lives before some of you get it? It's not about "freedom" vs "choice", it's about listening to science and doing what's best for the country. And btw, what's with all the personal attacks on Heather Hallett and the other experts involved in the inquiry? Can't we just have a civil discussion without resorting to insults? 😒
 
I gotta say, this lockdown thing has been super beneficial for public health 😒. I mean think about it, over 23k deaths saved because of lockdowns? That's not a mistake, that's a lifesaver 💀. The right-wing crowd just can't handle the fact that their precious "freedom" had to take a backseat to saving lives 🙅‍♂️. And let's be real, £410bn is a small price to pay for preserving human life 🤑. Politicians and policymakers need to stop playing politics with people's lives and just make informed decisions based on science 📊. The fact that some folks are still spouting anti-lockdown nonsense is just embarrassing 😳. We gotta call out this anti-science delusion for what it is – a bunch of ideological hogwash 💯.
 
man, this covid inquiry report is straight fire 🚒😱 23k deaths is crazy, can't believe Boris and co thought they could get away with that 🤦‍♂️ lockdowns were a risk, but the lives saved? that's hard to ignore ⏰ I mean, £410bn is a small price to pay for thousands of lives 💸 Daniel Hannan and Toby Young are just cherry-picking facts to fit their narrative 📝 it's like they're trying to erase what really happened during the pandemic 🕰️ can't let anti-science ideologies dictate our policies again 🚫 gotta keep the science in the mix, you know? 🧬
 
man 23k deaths in uk is crazy 🤯 lockdowns might've hurt econ but they saved so many lives its all about weighing costs vs benefits 📊💸 and honestly i think ppl need to stop demonizing scientists & experts who just tryin to do their job 👩‍🔬💡 instead of makin assumptions based on media sensationalism 📰😒
 
I mean, can you even believe the UK government's response to this Covid inquiry? It's like they're trying to downplay the severity of the pandemic and shift the blame onto scientists and experts. I've got a friend who lost her mum to Covid and she's still struggling to come to terms with what happened. The number 23,000 is just devastating and it's not something you can just brush off as a "mistake". I think it's crazy that some people are trying to say that lockdowns were pointless and even deadly. It's like they're putting politics over people's lives. 🤕 And what really gets me is that this anti-science delusion has become a defining feature of right-wing politics in the UK. It's like they're more concerned with ideology than actual human life. 😒
 
🤕 "The ultimate test of a man's character is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy." 🌪️
 
the problem here isn't just about politics, its about people losing their lives because of someone else's fear & ego 🤕... lockdowns might've been hard, but they saved countless lives... what's the point of having freedom if we're gonna keep sacrificing our humanity in the process? 🙅‍♂️ we need to remember that science isn't just about numbers & stats, its about people's lives and making sacrifices for the greater good 💯... let's not forget what happened during covid, it's a harsh lesson but one we should learn from, and move forward as a society with empathy and compassion 🤝
 
🤔 I mean, think about it, lockdowns were basically just a temporary measure to slow down the spread of Covid-19, right? 🚪 I'm not saying they didn't have some negative effects on the economy, but come on, 23,000 deaths? That's still a pretty big number, and we can't just ignore the fact that lockdowns likely saved countless more lives. 💀 It's also worth noting that the UK's death toll was way higher than many other countries that didn't have lockdowns in place. Maybe, just maybe, we should be looking at what went right with lockdowns instead of trying to discredit them? 🤷‍♂️
 
😱 just read about the Covid inquiry's report on Boris Johnson's inaction during the pandemic 🤯 I'm still trying to wrap my head around the estimated 23,000 deaths... it's mind-boggling 💀 and honestly, I think we're seeing a super concerning trend of anti-science thinking among right-wing politicians 👥 like Daniel Hannan and Toby Young are just pushing this narrative that lockdowns were pointless 🚫 what about all the lives lost?! £410bn is a crazy amount to spend on "freedom"... how can policymakers not consider public health safety above ideology? 🤝 we need to hold these folks accountable for their decisions 💪
 
man, can you believe this 🤯? like I remember when we were all still trying to figure out how to use those new-fangled Zoom meetings back in 2020 📹, and now they're questioning the whole lockdown thing? it's like, come on guys, 23,000 people lost their lives because of Boris's denial 🤕. and you know what really gets me? the media is just eating it up 💔 like they're all one big Brexit-supporting choir 🎶.

and don't even get me started on these lockdown sceptics who think they're some kind of heroes for speaking truth to power 💪. newsflash, mate: there's no such thing as a free lunch 🍴... unless you're willing to sacrifice thousands of lives at the altar of ideology 💔.

i mean, what's next? are we going to start questioning the safety of seatbelts and vaccination too? 🚗💉 come on, guys, get some perspective here!
 
omg u cant believe the ppl who supported lockdowns are now tryin 2 downplay the deaths they caused its like, we all know the risks & we took action 2 protect ppl lives but now theres this whole "mistake" thing goin around which is straight up misleading ther wasnt just 1 right decision that led 2 everythin but a bunch of tiny choices that added up 🤯 and btw what about all the ppl who didnt die? that's some serious anti-science nonsense im so over it 🙄
 
🤔 I'm still trying to wrap my head around all this COVID stuff... like, I get why lockdowns were a hard decision but 23k deaths is crazy to think about 🤯. It feels like the right-wing side of politics are just ignoring science and putting "freedom" over people's lives 💔. I mean, Daniel Hannan and Toby Young can say all they want but at what cost? Their party's attitude towards public health is so reckless it's frightening 😬. What's even more disturbing is that this kind of anti-science thinking has become a norm in their politics 🤷‍♀️. We need to start questioning whether "freedom" really means sacrificing lives 💀.
 
🚨 I'm still shook by this Covid inquiry's findings on Boris Johnson 🤯. 23,000 deaths is a chilling number that'll forever be etched in our memories 💔. It's appalling how the right-wing media landscape has been quick to reject science and life-saving interventions 🚫. The attacks on the lockdown report are shameful, especially from Daniel Hannan and Toby Young 🤦‍♂️.

What I find disturbing is that this anti-science delusion has become a defining feature of UK politics 📊. Johnson's remarks about "letting bodies pile high" are a stark illustration of his party's cavalier attitude towards public health 🚑. The cost of lockdowns was worth it – we can't put a price on lives lost 💸.

The House of Commons library estimated the cost of lockdowns could've been as high as £410bn 🤯. The real question is, will policymakers use this evidence to inform future decisions? I hope they do 🔍. We need to confront the right's predilection for "freedom" over lifesaving measures and expose ideology-driven narratives that justify sacrificing lives 💥.
 
🤦‍♂️ I'm still trying to wrap my head around the number 23,000... it's just mind-boggling to think about how many lives were lost because of the UK government's inaction during the pandemic 🤕. I think it's really telling that right-wing politicians are now denying the effectiveness of lockdowns and claiming they're a "mistake" 💔. It's like they're trying to rewrite history or something... 😒

I do think, though, that the cost of lockdowns was worth it in terms of saving lives. I mean, £410bn might seem like a lot, but what's the value of thousands of human lives? 🤷‍♂️ It's not just about the money, either - it's about public health and safety. We need politicians who are willing to put the needs of their citizens above ideological convictions 💯.

It's also worth noting that this isn't just about Covid-19 or lockdowns... it's a bigger issue about the role of science in politics 📊. If right-wing politicians continue to reject scientific advice and ignore evidence, we're going to be in trouble down the line 🚨. We need more critical thinking and less ideology-driven decision-making 👎
 
Back
Top