'Bad girls' is how society labels women in prison. But what if that label is a lie? | Sabrina Mahtani

The label "bad girls" is one that society attaches to women in prison, but is it fair? Research by Women Beyond Walls and Penal Reform International reveals that the majority of women are imprisoned for non-violent crimes, such as poverty-related offenses or mental illness. This raises questions about the stigma surrounding incarceration and the need to challenge societal attitudes towards women who have been convicted of crimes.

One woman in Pollsmoor prison in South Africa shared her story of being arrested for shoplifting while trying to feed her family. In Sierra Leone, I documented numerous cases of women being arrested for owing money or selling food without a license to make ends meet. These stories highlight the harsh realities faced by women who are often forced into poverty and desperation.

The "war on drugs" is also fuelling an increase in women's incarceration in Latin America and Asia. Many women sell drugs due to coercion or poverty, making them easier targets for police trying to meet quotas.

However, the reality is that most women who commit violent crimes are survivors of violence themselves. Chisomo from Malawi was arrested after she killed her ex-partner, who had sexually assaulted her and threatened to kill her if she left him.

Despite these efforts, a legal system built by men and for men continues to fail women through sexism and gender bias. Women who do not fit traditional stereotypes of the moral and motherly woman are often punished more harshly.

Prisons are not safe spaces for women. Vulnerable women often go into prison and come out further traumatized. Invasive strip-searches, solitary confinement, and other practices can cause harm to women with histories of sexual abuse or mental health challenges.

The intergenerational harms of parental imprisonment on children are well-documented. I once tried to trace the children of a desperate mother in Sierra Leone, who had no idea what happened to them after she was arrested. A neighbor had taken them in, but the nine-year-old girl went missing while trying to make ends meet.

High-level forums on women's rights often overlook this issue, despite the UN Commission on the Status of Women's pledge to "leave no one behind." Organizations working with and for incarcerated women are underfunded, even by donors to human rights and women's rights causes.

However, there is hope. Women around the world are reimagining what justice could look like, from inside and outside prison walls. Innovative laws allowing women to serve community sentences instead of imprisonment have been passed in some countries.

In Sierra Leone, I worked with a feminist legal group to challenge colonial-era loitering laws. In the UK, women's centers offer a model of community support that is more effective and less costly than prison.

The International Network of Formerly Incarcerated Women brings together women from over 30 countries to share their experiences and work towards systemic change. As the number of women in prison continues to grow, it is essential that we hold governments accountable for their failure to implement UN standards and lack of investment in alternatives to incarceration.

Reducing women's mass incarceration must be a global priority so that marginalized women and their children stop being punished for systemic injustice. Prison is a feminist issue that is deeply intertwined with other women's rights struggles, including gender-based violence, reproductive rights, and poverty.
 
πŸ˜’ I'm not buying the 'bad girls' label just yet. These stories about women in prison are super compelling but let's be real, most of them aren't even violent offenders. Like what's the crime rate for men? Should we be labeling guys who sell dodgy goods or get into bar brawls with a similar stigma? πŸ€”

And don't even get me started on this "war on drugs" thing. It sounds like a convenient excuse for governments to lock up more people, regardless of their circumstances. What about the economic factors that lead to women selling goods on the black market? Shouldn't we be addressing poverty and inequality instead of stigmatizing vulnerable women? πŸ’Έ

I'd love to see some concrete data on how many women are arrested for non-violent crimes versus violent ones. And what's with the claim that most women who commit violent crimes are survivors of violence themselves? Isn't that a pretty simplistic explanation? We need more nuance here.

And have you seen these prisons and their conditions? That's just wrong. Women in prison should be provided with support services, not subjected to strip-searches and solitary confinement like they're some kind of common criminals. 🚫
 
🀯 this is just not right we need to rethink the whole justice system, its like we punish these women for trying to survive in a world thats not fair on them many of them are forced into crime by circumstances, mental health or poverty so our prisons should be places of healing and rehabilitation not punishment. 🚫
 
πŸ€• Prisons are literally prisons πŸš” not homes for women! They're already dealing with so much trauma from society, why would you wanna throw 'em in a tiny cell and give 'em more to deal with? 🀯 It's like, what's the logic behind that? Just because they committed a crime doesn't mean they need to be locked up. Maybe we should be looking at how we can help them get back on their feet instead of making it harder for 'em to survive outside. πŸ’Έ And don't even get me started on the stigma around being a "bad girl"... that's just crazy talk πŸ˜‚. We need to start seeing women as human beings, not just their crimes. πŸ™
 
🚫 prisons are not the answer πŸ’” the intergenerational harm to kids when mums get locked up is real & devastating πŸ‘Ά my heart goes out to all those women who have been forced into poverty & desperation by circumstances beyond their control 🀯 we need to rethink our entire justice system from the ground up πŸ’‘
 
can u believe the stats on women in prison? like, its not even about them committing crimes but because they gotta make ends meet 🀯 i mean think about it, selling food or owing money is basically just trying to survive. and yet these women are locked up for it while guys get a slap on the wrist for the same thing. its all about how we treat women in society, you know? like, mental health and poverty are major issues that need to be addressed 🀝
 
can't believe how unfair the prison system is towards women 🀯 it's like they're trying to punish us even more when we're already struggling to survive. most of them end up in there for non-violent crimes like poverty-related offenses or mental illness... like who doesn't know someone with a mental health crisis? πŸ’” and these invasive strip-searches and solitary confinement practices are literally torturing women who have already been traumatized.

and don't even get me started on the intergenerational harms of parental imprisonment on kids πŸ€• it's heartbreaking to think about those little ones growing up without their moms. we need to rethink what justice looks like and prioritize community support over prison time πŸ’– some countries are starting to do this right, like with innovative laws that allow women to serve community sentences instead of being locked away.

it's all about challenging societal attitudes towards women who have made mistakes πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ but not necessarily in a bad way... we're human, we make mistakes. and it's time for governments to hold themselves accountable for their failure to implement UN standards and invest in alternatives to incarceration πŸ’ͺ we can do better!
 
women in prison are not bad girls they r victims of circumstance πŸ˜” the system failed them just like it failed her in pollsmoor prison who was arrested for shoplifting 2 feed her fam πŸ€• what about all the women who get coerced or manipulated into selling drugs? u think thats a choice? πŸ€‘ we gotta rethink this whole 'war on drugs' thing & its impact on women's lives πŸ’”
 
I mean, can you believe how far we've come in understanding that locking up women who are struggling to make ends meet isn't the answer? I remember watching those old episodes of Oprah where she'd talk about women getting locked up for not being able to afford food πŸ˜‚. It's just crazy how society would shame these women instead of helping them out.

I'm so done with this "bad girls" label. Like, what even is that? Women who get arrested aren't bad; they're just trying to survive. And it's getting worse, especially in Latin America and Asia where the war on drugs is causing a lot more harm than good 🀯. I mean, have you seen those reports about women being sold drugs because of coercion or poverty? It's heartbreaking.

And don't even get me started on how prisons aren't safe spaces for women πŸ˜”. They're already vulnerable, and then they get thrown into solitary confinement or strip-searched... it's just traumatic. And what really breaks my heart is what happens to their kids when mom gets locked up πŸ€•. It's like, can't we see that this is a systemic issue?

But you know what? I'm hopeful 😊. There are women out there who are reimagining justice and finding new ways to help each other out. Like, have you heard about those community sentences in some countries? That's like, the opposite of prison 🀝.

We need more awareness about this issue, and we need to hold governments accountable for not doing enough. It's time to make reducing women's mass incarceration a global priority πŸ’ͺ. We can do better than this! πŸ‘
 
The more I read about these women in prison, the more it feels like we're dealing with a society that disproportionately targets already vulnerable people - especially those living in poverty. 🀯 It's like we're trying to keep them locked up so they don't disrupt our system. Newsflash: that's not justice, that's just bad policy.

I mean think about it, most of these women aren't even violent offenders... they're just trying to survive. And the fact that we're still using outdated laws and practices to deal with poverty-related offenses is a clear sign of sexism in our legal system. We need to rethink how we approach justice and make sure it's more inclusive and supportive.

And don't even get me started on the trauma these women face behind bars. It's like, can't we do better than locking up vulnerable people and then expecting them to "rehabilitate" or whatever? No, it's time for a radical shift in how we approach incarceration and support our most marginalized communities.

The numbers are clear: more women in prison = more systemic problems. It's time for us to take responsibility for creating a system that truly supports people, rather than just locking them up. πŸ’ͺ
 
omg i just read this article about women in prison and it's wild how many of them are arrested for stuff like not paying bills or trying to feed their fams 🀯 and it makes me think about my own family and how hard it is when ppl are struggling financially πŸ€‘ idk what the solution is but it feels like we need to rethink our whole approach to crime and punishment πŸ€”
 
🚨 the whole "bad girls" thing is super unfair πŸ˜’, especially when it comes to women who are locked up for non-violent stuff like trying to feed their families or dealing with poverty πŸ’Έ. they're not all bad, you know? πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ i mean, one woman in south africa got arrested for shoplifting 'cause she was struggling to put food on the table... how can that even be a crime? πŸ€” and then there's this whole "war on drugs" thing that's pushing women into incarceration who are just trying to make ends meet πŸ’Ž. we need to rethink our approach to justice, especially when it comes to women 🌟
 
Back
Top