The $500 billion beauty industry’s ‘green’ ambitions are a patchwork at best. And they’re falling short | CNN

The $500 billion global beauty industry has set ambitious environmental goals, but its efforts to become more sustainable are proving to be a patchwork at best.

According to a recent study by strategy and consulting firm Simon Kucher, 60% of consumers worldwide consider sustainability an important purchase criterion, with 35% willing to pay more for eco-friendly products. This shift in consumer preferences has prompted many beauty brands to set environmental goals, such as phasing out single-use plastics and using recyclable, reusable, or refillable packaging.

However, consumers continue to struggle to understand the sustainability credentials of many products due to inconsistent industry efforts and a lack of transparency. The British Beauty Council notes that "greenwashing" - where companies make unsubstantiated sustainability claims - is common in the beauty industry.

The use of marketing terms like "clean beauty" has become increasingly problematic, with some critics arguing that these buzzwords are used to sell more products rather than drive meaningful change. Industry leaders and experts stress the need for better transparency and certification standards, particularly when it comes to ingredient sourcing and packaging materials.

One major challenge facing the industry is plastic packaging, which accounts for 67% of its packaging volume. The cosmetics business is one of the biggest users of plastic packaging globally, with beauty giants like L'Oréal and Estee Lauder Companies using massive amounts of plastic in their packaging material each year. However, recycling rates are low, and demand for post-consumer recycled (PCR) plastic is high due to supply chain limitations.

Beauty retailers also play a pivotal role in promoting sustainability, but many vary when it comes to setting standards for the brands they sell. While some companies have launched initiatives like Sephora's "Clean + Planet Positive" program or Target's "Target Zero" icon, others lack transparency and accountability.

The missing piece of the puzzle is regulation and standardization. Certifications like B Corp are beneficial, but their voluntary nature limits their impact. Governments and multinationals enforcing regulations and setting a baseline for sustainability claims would help drive meaningful change in the industry. Industry leaders emphasize that market leadership is key to driving climate-conscious change.

In the absence of bold regulations or global standards on sustainability practices, this "leadership" - undertaken by brands and customers alike in the beauty marketplace - will likely be the most impactful vector for addressing the industry's climate shortcomings. It will take continued collective advocacy and initiative to drive meaningful climate-conscious change in the $500 billion global beauty industry.
 
I think its really frustrating that the beauty industry is making sustainability claims left and right, but its all so inconsistent 🤔. Like, some companies are totally on top of their game with refillable packaging and sourcing ingredients from sustainable suppliers, but then you've got others just slapping "clean" on a product and calling it a day 😒. It's like they're just trying to sell more stuff rather than actually making changes that benefit the planet.

We need more transparency and regulation in this industry, for sure 💪. The fact that some companies are doing great but many others are not holding them up is a huge problem. And what's with the lack of standardization? It's like they're all just winging it 🤷‍♀️. We need governments and multinationals to step in and set some baseline standards for sustainability claims, or else we'll never really see meaningful change happen.

I'm glad there are brands out there that are taking this seriously, though 💯. Sephora's program is a great example of what can be achieved when companies prioritize sustainability. And customers are also making their voices heard, which is awesome 🙌. It just goes to show that even in the beauty industry, we can make a difference if we work together and demand better from our brands 💕
 
🌎💡 so i think its crazy how much pressure consumers are putting on big beauty brands to go sustainable... 60% of people care about it that's like a huge chunk of the market 🤑 but meanwhile, greenwashing is still super common... its like companies just slap these eco-friendly labels on their products and call it a day... i mean we need real transparency and certification standards here 📝

and oh man plastic packaging is a whole different beast 🌪️ its crazy how much plastic the industry uses and then they expect us to recycle it all... but recycling rates are so low 🤦‍♀️ and supply chain limitations make it hard to get PCR plastic on a large scale... i wish there was more regulation and standardization in place 💼

anyway, i think its cool that some brands like Sephora and Target are taking the lead on sustainability initiatives 🌟 but we need more of them to follow suit 👏 and governments need to step up their game too ⚖️

for now, it's all about market leadership and customer pressure driving change 💪🌎
 
🤔 I mean, have you ever stopped to think about what drives us to care so much about sustainability when it comes to beauty products? 🌿 Is it really just about reducing our carbon footprint or is there something deeper at play? 🤝 I think we're trying to compensate for the emptiness within ourselves by making external choices that make us feel more connected to the world around us. 💁‍♀️ The fact that consumers are willing to pay more for eco-friendly products suggests that we're desperate for a sense of meaning and purpose in our purchasing decisions. 📈 It's like, we want to believe that our beauty habits can somehow create a better world, but is that just a way to distract ourselves from our own existential crises? 💔 The industry's reliance on marketing terms like "clean beauty" is also revealing – it's like they're trying to sell us a sense of self-worth rather than actually changing their practices. 🎀 Can we really trust the language and claims made by brands, or are we just being sold a bill of goods? 💸 It's clear that regulation and standardization are needed to drive meaningful change, but I'm not convinced it's just about policy changes – there needs to be a fundamental shift in how we think about consumption and sustainability. 🌎
 
omg u know i was thinkin how crazy its that people r gettin all upset about greenwashing in the beauty industry lol like yeah we get it, some companies r just tryna save face instead of actually makin changes 😂

anywayz im thinkin we need 2 b more strict w/ certificatons & regulations so ppl know whats up w/ sustainability claims. its not fair 2 consumers who wanna make eco-friendly choices but dont no what 2 look 4.

also, i feel like beauty retailers need 2 step up their game 🤔 theyre supposed 2 b promoting sustainability but instead its just a bunch of buzzwords & marketing tricks. we need transparency & accountability 4real!

and lets be realz, plastic packaging is still a major issue 🤯 how can we expect sustainability when we r still usin so much single-use plastics? industry leaders need 2 take bold action & not just say they care about sustainability 🙄

but, i guess its good 2 hear that consumers are gettin more eco-conscious 🌿 like, we're all in this together & all dat 💖 maybe w/ enough pressure & advocacy, we can drive meaningful change in the beauty industry
 
I mean think about it, we're at a point where consumers are super aware of sustainability and they're willing to pay more for eco-friendly products 🤑. But what's crazy is that companies aren't always being transparent about their efforts or what goes into those products. It's like this whole "greenwashing" thing is just a thing now 😒.

And I'm not even getting started on plastic packaging, 67% of the industry's packaging volume and it's basically unsustainable 🌎. We need some real leadership in this space, you know? Like, governments and multinationals stepping up to set some standards for sustainability claims or regulations that actually make a difference.

But honestly, I think the most powerful force here is just going to be consumers demanding better from companies. We can't rely on just "leadership" or certifications; we need real action 💪. It's like, what even does it mean for a product to be "clean"? Is that just a marketing term now? 🤔
 
the thing is, i think we're all caught up in this whole eco-friendly vibe and it's kinda cool that people are willing to pay more for sustainable products 🌎 but come on, how hard can it be to make a few changes? like, l'oreal uses 67% of plastic packaging and estee lauder companies are huge users too... it's not like they're just "greenwashing" their image or something 💸 the problem is that consumers are still kinda clueless about what makes products sustainable 🤔 and it's all because of industry inconsistency. i mean, we need better transparency and certification standards for sure, but regulation and standardization would be the game changer here 🔒
 
its not all bad tho 🤗, people are finally waking up to the importance of sustainability. those 35% willing to pay more for eco-friendly products is a big step forward 💸🌎 and its awesome that brands like Sephora and Target are taking the lead on this 🙌. but we need to see more transparency and standardization in the industry, thats where regulations come in 👍. maybe we can't get governments to act fast enough, but its great that industry leaders are taking initiative and pushing for change 💪
 
I'm really concerned about the state of sustainability in the beauty industry 🤕. I mean, 60% of consumers are like "sustainability is a must" but it's not translating into real change. The whole industry is just patching things up with some eco-friendly packaging and calling it a day 💼. And don't even get me started on greenwashing - it's getting out of hand! 🚮

I think we need to see more transparency from brands, like how they're sourcing their ingredients and where their waste is going. And let's be real, plastic packaging is a major issue 📦. I mean, 67% of the industry's packaging volume is just plastic... it's crazy! 💥

But you know what's even crazier? How some brands are doing the bare minimum on sustainability while others are like "oh, we're totally committed to the cause" 🙄. It's not about being a leader, it's about following some basic guidelines and setting a baseline for what's acceptable.

I think we need to see more regulation and standardization in this industry 📝. Like, if governments and multinationals can enforce some basic rules, that would help drive change. But at the end of the day, it's up to us consumers to keep pushing for better practices 💪.
 
The beauty industry is literally playing dress-up when it comes to sustainability 🤣... I mean, they're trying their best, but it's like, how many times can you say "clean" before it just becomes a buzzword? 💁‍♀️ For real tho, transparency and accountability are key. We need more standards and regulations in place so we know what we're getting when we buy eco-friendly products. Like, if Sephora's program is the gold standard, why aren't other brands following suit? 🤔 It's not just about the companies making changes, it's about consumers demanding it too. If we want a more sustainable beauty industry, we need to be willing to hold these companies accountable and support those that are leading the way. 💪
 
💁‍♀️ I'm so done with the beauty industry's greenwashing 🌱🚮! Like, come on guys, we all know it's just a marketing ploy 🤑 to sell more products 💄. They're still using massive amounts of plastic packaging and claiming they're being sustainable? 😒 Give me a break! The consumers are getting smarter and 60% of them want eco-friendly products, but the industry is just patchy 🛠️.

And don't even get me started on "clean beauty" 💅. It's like they're using buzzwords to sell more stuff 📦 rather than actually making a change. The industry needs to step up its game and provide transparency and certification standards ⚖️, especially when it comes to ingredient sourcing and packaging materials.

The thing is, regulation and standardization are needed 💪. B Corp certifications are great, but they're just that - voluntary 🤔. We need governments and multinationals to enforce regulations and set a baseline for sustainability claims 🔒.

But until then, it's up to the brands and customers to lead the way 👊. Market leadership is key to driving climate-conscious change, so let's hope these companies can do better 💚!
 
🤕 the beauty industry is just another example of how corporate America is all about profits over people... 60% of consumers care about sustainability but are we really making progress? 📉 I mean, if only 50% of the major brands can agree on some standards for eco-friendliness then what's the point? 💸 the whole "clean beauty" thing just sounds like marketing speak to me. 💁‍♀️ and don't even get me started on the packaging - it's literally killing our oceans 🌊
 
🤔 I think the beauty industry is at a crucial crossroads 🚨. They're talking the talk, but not always walking the walk 🙅‍♂️. We need stricter regulations and standardized certifications to ensure sustainability claims are legit 📊. It's frustrating when we can't trust what we see on packaging or ads 💔. The industry leaders think market pressure will drive change, but I'm skeptical ⚠️. Let's be real, some brands just want to sell more products 🤑 and might not care about the environmental impact 😒. We need a systemic shift towards sustainability, not just a few token initiatives 🎉.
 
I'm feeling kinda frustrated when I think about the beauty industry trying to be eco-friendly but not being transparent enough 🤕. Like, we want to support brands that are making an effort, but it's hard to know which ones are really doing their part. And yeah, "clean beauty" can sound great on paper, but if it's just a marketing term without actual substance, then what's the point? 😒

I do think it's awesome that some brands like Sephora and Target are taking steps in the right direction with their sustainability initiatives 🌟. But we need to see more consistency across the industry, you know? And yeah, regulation might be a bit scary for some companies, but I think it would ultimately help drive real change 🤝.

What really gets me is that consumers are willing to pay more for eco-friendly products, which means brands should be investing in sustainable practices already 💸. It's not like we're asking for the moon here... just basic transparency and accountability would go a long way 🙏.
 
the problem is that these big beauty companies are trying to save face by setting some half-baked goals, but really they're just using it as an excuse to keep on selling the same old products 🤔. and don't even get me started on the "clean beauty" label - it's just a marketing gimmick if you ask me 💁‍♀️. what we need is real transparency and regulation, not just a bunch of feel-good initiatives that don't actually make a difference.
 
You know what's wild? I just got back from the most random road trip last weekend 🚗😅. I ended up driving through this tiny town that had the most adorable thrift store. I spent like 20 minutes browsing through old clothes and found these super comfy vintage denim shorts 👖👕. The best part? They were literally one dollar! 💸 I know it sounds silly, but there's something about thrift shopping that just feels so freeing 😌.

Anyway, back to the beauty industry... I think what really needs to happen is for consumers to be more vocal about their preferences 🗣️. We need to hold these companies accountable for their sustainability claims and make sure they're being transparent 📊. It's not enough for them just to say they're "committing" to sustainability; we need to see real action and results 💪.

And can I just say, the term "greenwashing" is so overused? 🙄 It sounds like a buzzword that brands use to make themselves sound good, but it's actually a legitimate concern. We need to be critical of these claims and not just blindly trust them 🔍.
 
ugh, it's so frustrating to see how much the beauty industry can do better 🤯💪. they're always like 'oh, we care about sustainability' but then you look into it and it's just a bunch of marketing speak 💁‍♀️. clean beauty this, eco-friendly that... where are the results? 📊

i think what really needs to happen is some serious regulation and standardization 🚫💼. like, we need laws and stuff that hold companies accountable for their claims 🤦‍♂️. and not just voluntary certifications that don't count for much 🤑.

but despite all the flaws, i still see glimmers of hope 💡🌟. companies are starting to take action and consumers are speaking up 🗣️💬. and yeah, it's true that we need more transparency and better labeling ⚖️📝.

anyway, let's keep pushing for change 🔄💪. we can do this! 💕
 
🤔 I mean, come on guys! 🙄 The beauty industry is all about looking good, but when it comes to sustainability, they're all over the place 🌈. Consumers are getting more eco-aware and want to know what's in their products, but brands are still being kinda shady 🤥. It's like, "Oh, we're clean beauty now" 🙄, but is that just a fancy marketing term? 📦

And don't even get me started on plastic packaging 🚮. We need better recycling rates and more transparency around ingredient sourcing 💡. But what's really needed is regulation and standardization 🛑️. Like, come on governments and big brands, let's step up our game 🔝.

I love that Sephora is doing its part with the "Clean + Planet Positive" program 🌟, but we need more of that on a global scale 🌎. We can't just rely on industry leadership (and let's be real, some brands are just trying to greenwash their way to sales 💸). We need bold change and it needs to come from the top 🔥.
 
Ugh man, I'm tellin' ya... 😩 the beauty industry is all about appearances right now. They're talkin' about bein' sustainable and eco-friendly, but when you scratch beneath the surface, it's like, "where's the proof?" 🤔 I mean, 60% of consumers care about sustainability, but what's the industry doin' to back it up? Just a bunch of greenwashin', if you ask me... 💚

And don't even get me started on plastic packaging. It's like, we know it's bad for the planet, but we're still usin' loads of it and expectin' consumers to just roll with it? 🤷‍♂️ Come on, industry leaders, step up your game! We need regulation and standardization, not just a bunch of feel-good initiatives. 💪
 
Ugh man I'm so done with the whole beauty industry being all over the place when it comes to sustainability 🤯💄. Like 60% of consumers care about eco-friendliness but you can't even find a straight answer on what that means for most products. And don't even get me started on "clean beauty" - it's just a buzzword that's supposed to make you feel good but ultimately doesn't really change anything 🤷‍♀️.

I mean I love Sephora's initiatives as much as the next person, but when are we gonna see some real regulation around packaging and ingredient sourcing? It's not like L'Oréal and Estee Lauder just magically started caring about sustainability overnight 💁‍♀️. It's all about market leadership and what consumers want, which is great... until it isn't.

I guess the thing that gets me most is how low recycling rates are, especially for plastic packaging 🤯. We need some serious changes in the industry ASAP or else we're gonna be stuck in this toxic cycle of consumption forever 💔.
 
Back
Top